Rogue poisons permament request.

[Puupi]

1 hour long SELF buffs are a pointless mechanic and a waste of a button.

Just make them passive effects of the class/spec.

[Monoxide]

It's one of Blizzards derp moments where their devs brains aren't working properly. Sorry, that might seem harsh, but it's been 15 years and poisons aren't permanent buffs/enchants. How does it take 15 years to not even implement it yet, when playing the game for 1 hour makes ANY normal person think "well reapplying is annoying, this should be permanent"...

People like you are why retail sucks.

1 hour long SELF buffs are a pointless mechanic and a waste of a button.

Just make them passive effects of the class/spec.

and you

Front page says otherwise:

World of Warcraft Classic drove the biggest quarterly increase to subscription plans in franchise history, in both the West and East.

[jellmoo]

I mean, Blizzard could just as easily look at this, say you're right and that a 1 hour buff for poisons doesn't make any sense. And then reduce it a 5 minute buff.

[Polarthief]

I sort of get it, but... I still like putting on my poisons. Just a little moment of RP I guess. Regardless I've been playing Rogue forever so I wind up doing it at least once every 30 minutes anyway.

I'd say you still can; don't make them passive, just make them last until you switch specs/you manually turn them off.

[Twdft]

And here I am wishing I could brew my own poisons again.

Permanent poisons are just a buff you don't think about. Why even have a button then, to press it once when you login?

[Reinaerd]

People like you are why retail sucks.



and you




Front page says otherwise:

I know Sherlock, i play classic, rarely log retail. But every time there's a post about a change idea in retail, every asperger suffering sack of human suck pops into the thread going.


OH YOU GUYS WANT CLASSIC.

No they don't, which is why they play retail. Their idea on a game mechanic change only concerns retail.
So why pop into the thread going I PLAY VANILLA... what.. you want a participation medal or some shit.
You don't even bother answering the actual question.

And people like you are why online communities suck.

[Doctor Funkenstein]

I like the people who think "having to reapply a buff out of combat every X minutes" is what makes a game fun.

It's amazing how some people's brains work.

[therealstegblob]

And your lack of anything at all shows that, does it?

1.) It's a fucking game mechanic, it doesn't really need to adhere to total sense. Back in the day, poisons even had stacks that wore off over time, but they removed that long ago.

2.) What's to say a Paladin's aura or whatever should be permanent, anyways? Why should ANY buff be considered to be theoretically permanent?

3.) You talked about "replacing enchants" (fucking what?). The OP is not asking for poisons to work as some kind of enchant, they're asking for the buff duration to extend from 60 minutes to have no time limit and only un-apply when cancelled or replaced by a different poison. You're apparently from England, yet you don't seem to speak English?

Your argument was stupid.

- - - Updated - - -

Permanent poisons are just a buff you don't think about. Why even have a button then, to press it once when you login?

That would be the basic definition of a buff that doesn't expire, yes.

[perkocet]

People like you are why retail sucks.



and you




Front page says otherwise:

Didn't WOD also do this, for like a month?

[analmoose]

It's one of Blizzards derp moments where their devs brains aren't working properly. Sorry, that might seem harsh, but it's been 15 years and poisons aren't permanent buffs/enchants. How does it take 15 years to not even implement it yet, when playing the game for 1 hour makes ANY normal person think "well reapplying is annoying, this should be permanent"...

Muhhh Immerssioonnsss, just like running on a running mount is way more fun and interesting than flying

[Kaver]

I love that the third comment on the us wow forum is “this change would be an objectively positive one.”

... objectively positive...

Hmmmm I guess this is just the world we live in now... in 2019... where feelings count more as an argument than facts...

Unless the person is talking about the positive charge of a proton of course.. I guess you can say that a proton is objectively positive.

[glowpipe]

This, kids, is how you get retail WoW.

I'll be over there in Classic enjoying the inclusion of RPG elements in my RPGs.

enjoy your roleplay as a manual laborer doing menial tasks. So important, much wow

Its not like its a passive buff, you still apply the poison you want to use. But its outright retarded that you need to reapply it every 60 minutes when its not even a consumable anymore

- - - Updated - - -

Didn't WOD also do this, for like a month?

Bfa was also the fastest selling wow expansion of all times. See how well that went..

[Frenegade42]

Hi all! Ive made a thread on official forums, a request to Blizzard to make them permament once applied instead of 60 minutes.

If you agree with this, if you want this to be a thing please leave a comment, maybe Blizzard reads on it and considers the idea.

Poisons are not a group buff, poisons are personal and like other personal buffs in game there is no reason to not make it permament.

If this change makes no difference to you please consider giving support. Thanks!

https://us.forums.blizzard.com/en/wo...applied/352995

Thanks for reading and apologies if you think this is dumb and dont like the idea. I have no intentions to piss anyone off.

Look at this guy, petitioning for more pruning.

[Soisoisoi]

1.) It's a fucking game mechanic, it doesn't really need to adhere to total sense. Back in the day, poisons even had stacks that wore off over time, but they removed that long ago.

2.) What's to say a Paladin's aura or whatever should be permanent, anyways? Why should ANY buff be considered to be theoretically permanent?

3.) You talked about "replacing enchants" (fucking what?). The OP is not asking for poisons to work as some kind of enchant, they're asking for the buff duration to extend from 60 minutes to have no time limit and only un-apply when cancelled or replaced by a different poison. You're apparently from England, yet you don't seem to speak English?

Your argument was stupid. .

1) No shit, that doesn't mean it's something that should be apply and ignore. You might as well make them passive debuffs at that point that apply from spells.

2) Never said they should, but they are the only type of buff that has no duration. It's an example. If only you could apply simple thought before you replied, your last two replies shows you can't so far.

3) If you use your noggin' you'd realise if the weapon enhancements are permanent they are no different from weapon enchants at that point, and we all know Blizz being Blizz they'd end up doing something stupid and saying Rogues get poisons instead of Enchants.

Not my fault you can't comprehend simple mechanics, the "arguement" isn't stupid when you consider Blizzard's stupid mechanic changes over the years. We want class mechanics that are useful not pointless. No wonder retail has gone to shit with people like you wanting this shit. :/

[therealstegblob]

1) No shit, that doesn't mean it's something that should be apply and ignore. You might as well make them passive debuffs at that point that apply from spells.

2) Never said they should, but they are the only type of buff that has no duration. It's an example. If only you could apply simple thought before you replied, your last two replies shows you can't so far.

3) If you use your noggin' you'd realise if the weapon enhancements are permanent they are no different from weapon enchants at that point, and we all know Blizz being Blizz they'd end up doing something stupid and saying Rogues get poisons instead of Enchants.

Not my fault you can't comprehend simple mechanics, the "arguement" isn't stupid when you consider Blizzard's stupid mechanic changes over the years. We want class mechanics that are useful not pointless. No wonder retail has gone to shit with people like you wanting this shit. :/

Do you literally just never get tired of everyone rolling their eyes and shaking their heads every single time you post?

[Khaza-R]

I personally think they should go back to being craftable.

They also need to usable in all specs

[dcc626]

I personally think they should go back to being craftable.

They also need to usable in all specs

"all specs will get back poisons!"

"can you make it a permanent buff so i can pretend i dont have it anymore?"

/sigh

[Anelya]

I sort of get it, but... I still like putting on my poisons. Just a little moment of RP I guess. Regardless I've been playing Rogue forever so I wind up doing it at least once every 30 minutes anyway.

This!
Heck, I reapply it before every other pull without even thinking about doing it.

[korijenkins]

I sort of get it, but... I still like putting on my poisons. Just a little moment of RP I guess. Regardless I've been playing Rogue forever so I wind up doing it at least once every 30 minutes anyway.

As a moment of RP, it would be better if it had its own animation, rather than just a generic crafting animation.

[StillMcfuu]

As a moment of RP, it would be better if it had its own animation, rather than just a generic crafting animation.

It used to be a crafting item, I think the animation is just keeping with that tradition.