Originally Posted by
Magnecyl
Didn't we kill Smough at least? Kind of hard for him to transform and... you know, live if he's dead.
And Dancer's Soul state "The Pontiff Sulyvahn bestowed a double-slashing sword upon a distant daughter of the formal royal family, ordering her to serve first as a dancer, and then as an outrider knight, the equivalent to exile."
Doesn't really sound like Ciaran if you ask me but I have no real proof against it. Although I find it weird they would be all like "Hey, look, one of the most renowned knights in history! Let's make her a stripper."
All Outrider Knights of Ithiryll turn into beasts eventually, perhaps an Ashen Plague of sorts... There are many of them scattered around but smaller in size. So either Vordt and the Dancer are in the later stages of this sickness, they were much stronger than the others and therefor their new forms even more grotesquely malformed or they are simply more prone biologically to the transforming disease.
Like you I assumed the shadow-dragony things bursting out from the bodies of Hollows are indeed their humanity going wild. It looks very abyss-y if you ask me, combined with dragons. I also have absolutely no clue to the Hollow-trees scattered around the entirety of Lothric which kind of makes me sad as it was one of the first things that caught my attention. I like the archtree theory, like the world is slowly reverting back to it's previous state. A recurring theme in these games are cycles after all. But wasn't the fire fading in the first game too? And there there were no Hollow-trees that I can recall.
Something I haven't seen discussed is the eclipse. What are your thoughts of this? It doesn't start until the third Lord of Cinder is slain from what I've seen(although this might just be like in Bloodborne where the sky changes not because you killed a specific enemy but because time flows). It definitely doesn't look like a normal one to me. Could it be that the blackness seen is the very same substance the shadow dragons are made out of? The Abyss/humanity(whatever that is) slowly claiming the sun, another step in returning the world to its former state as I don't recall a sun in the first game's cinematic trailer. It does say "From the Dark they came, and found the souls of lords in the fire." which might just be humans coming from the abyss.