Just got back from seeing it in IMAX 3D and I LOVED IT. I Thought it was all very well done, the orcs were amazing - but dat Blackhand he's one ugly S.O.B. You cant expect the Lord of the Rings here guys, the lore was tweaked a bit but nothing to make a fuss over. Its an adaptation of a video game, and the best one I've ever seen. I don't know what all the hate and bad critiques are coming from. Just sit back and enjoy the movie like its supposed to be seen instead of ripping every little detail apart "like omg that's not canon!" or nitpicking tiny effect details. Having read this forum from all the usual negativity I went in expecting to be disappointed but wasn't, and I'm glad I went. I will recommend it to my friends and I hope they do make sequels.