Originally Posted by
Wingspan
As I remember it (take that for what it is worth):
The first week or two nearly all complaining was due to log in queues, which were horrible on many servers.
During the next couple of weeks, only the pro-flight crowd was generally upset. All was fresh and new so most people were happy, with a few (pvp, dumbing down, and other fairly typical gripes) as exceptions.
By about the end of the first month we had reached a "what now?" phase, where some started complaining about nothing to do, while others were saying there was tons of stuff to do. These threads really never let up, which was probably deserved. They reached an almost transcendent glory when the Twitter patch was launched... it was a sight to behold. (I think only the "RealNameID" event and the "No Flight Ever" event beat them our as rage points in the history of the game.)
It was probably sometime in the third month or so when people really started to turn on Garrisons... probably because by that point they had become too important to ignore AND because they became the biggest part of the game for many people.
Maybe a month later it was clear that very few people were truly happy, as subs dropped at a basically record pace (almost amazingly so).
I didn't even really play in the expansion but for one month at the end... but it was VERY entertaining to watch the saga play out. Every time I thought Blizzard was done dropping the ball, they seemed to say "But wait, there's less!"
Fun times.