You make no sense at all. Why would I have put my name in the hat for a piece of loot that wasn't an upgrade? At the same time a loot council wouldn't award a piece of loot that was a 1% upgrade versus someone that gained 5 or 10%. Loot drops every week as well so nothing will be perfect.
I'll bet the loot that people received this week from personal loot that's a downgrade really helped a raid team progress? Wrong. It sets them back.