Originally Posted by
Rocketbear
Care to enlighten me why you think that?
With personal loot, I've already several times gotten items I do not need, and some even warforge or titanforge yet are flat out worse than the item I already had, and thus couldn't trade them over to other people. With personal loot, that's the problem you have, your gear distribution will be suboptimal and it you will waste gear that otherwise could have been to use to others. Therefor your raid's gear progression, and by extension your overall progress, will suffer.
If your loot council has people in it above the age of 21, then you shouldn't really have issues.
If you feel like the guild gives others preferential treatment, leave the guild, find one who doesn't.