Well, it's because I'm not actually gimping my DPS I'm making it better by selecting those choices. I've run those scenarios and they don't come out anywhere near (in sims)
240 Seconds, Patchwerk again:
2213113 : 406K
2213313 : 415K
And the build you think should be the top performing spec?
1213133 : 355K
Buff up time on Meta goes from 34% with that Fel Mastery build you have, to 54% with the Blind Fury build I have and that is why the soul fragment build shines. Both Blind Fury and Demonic Appetite by themselves are pretty crappy. But pair them with Feast of Souls, and I usually come out of an 8 second Meta from an Eye beam with only 10 seconds left or so till the next Eye beam. Damage from Annihilation is double the damage from CS because you are in Meta so long. You think they are inferior because someone told you they were inferior. And I didn't post every single build I simed, just the ones that seem like they are feasible. Those three weren't feasible. What I am trying "to prove" as you say is that this strange build has numbers behind it that says it is competitive.... right now...according to a sim...With this many changes you need to sim yourself and see how things are shaking up. And in my own testing on Mr. Forgefiend these numbers seem to hold up, and the AoE numbers are actually much much better.
in a 4 minute fight with imps, I got 860K. It looked like this:
(I'm not actually trying to prove anything outside of it looks like Demon Hunters have actual options this patch instead of 99/100 DHs running the same spec.)