Uhh... what? Have you conveniently missed the interview clip that had been linked many times on the forums so far? The Blizzcon Q&A with Metzen and Afrasiabi, I meant. Here, I will even spend sometimes digging the transcript back up for you:
Originally Posted by Blizzard Entertainment
As you can see, the questioner were asking about the consequence of the two Old Gods' deaths. He wasn't asking "Who caused the Cataclysm?". The answer? "You know, like, when the world blows up? Because of the Old Gods". There you have it - the world blows up (in Cataclysm) because of the Old Gods' (deaths). Keep in mind that they weren't talking about the Old Gods' empowerment to Deathwing, they weren't talking about them corrupting and manipulating him - those were the actions when the two were alive. They were talking about the consequence of the two Old Gods' deaths - which was the world blowing up.
I'm not even sure why you are bringing up the fact that the Titans couldn't kill the Old Gods in the same manner as Aman'thul did, as it would open another wound on Azeroth. It has nothing to do with what is being discussed at hand, and it doesn't contradict what was said either. Nothing in Chronicle or anything released after that interview contradicted with it, actually. I'm always open to be corrected - feel free to give me the exact quote (and source) that stated either (1) C'Thun and Yogg's death didn't take any direct part in the Cataclysm, or (2) Deathwing and his followers were the only one responsible for Cataclysm, no one else. I'd be very happy to admit that it was retconned and I was wrong. We should base our argument around facts, no?
So yes, I would like to return what you said to you - you are entitled to believe in your headcanon if you wish. Or, to quote the WoG article on TVT: "It's important to remember that if you disagree with the Word of God, there's nothing wrong with writing fan fiction that contradicts it, just don't try to foist your preferred Fanon on fans who acknowledge the official canon or on the actual creator of the work". While it has been moving away, the original point was that the Old Gods' deaths (C'Thun and Yogg in particular) caused the Cataclysm (again, this doesn't mean Deathwing didn't cause it), as stated by WoG. If you don't believe it, well, see the quote few lines above.
That's wrong. It would only be 1 year if the events in TBC happened at the end of year 26 (for example, December), and the events in Cataclysm happened at the start of year 28 (for example, January). Otherwise, they would average out to be 2 years (26->27=1 year, 27->28=1year, 1+1=2 years). Similarly, WoTLK events to Cataclysm events would be 1 years (the entire of year 27). In fact, in "Shattering: Prelude to Cataclysm", before the first phase of the Elemental Unrest event, Anduin mentioned that it had been many months since the fall of Lich King and the supposed death of Bolvar ("Anduin had mourned the death of his friend Bolvar Fordragon, but the loss had been many months old by the time of the service").
So again, I bring up the issue that you keep ignoring - the earthquakes came months (almost a year) before the elements were disturbed (the time when the earthquakes intensified). If you are saying that Deathwing thrashing around in Deepholm was the only cause of those earthquakes, are you seriously saying that it took months of those thrashing for the elements to realized something was wrong?
However, yes, I believe both of us have stated our points, and it doesn't seem the discussion is going anywhere. I guess we'd have to agree to disagree on this one, then :P
Obviously it isn't. What was described there was the phases of the Elemental Unrest event (4.0.3 basically). The earthquakes intensified, elementals went chaotic and over time, eventually attack us. I have stated many times that I wasn't referring to those earthquakes during 4.0.3. The one I mentioned was the earthquake in 3.3.0 (during ICC - before Lich King was even died), the elements were pretty peaceful by then. Obviously, there weren't any "victorious Northrend expeditions" back then. Those two (earthquakes started before our assault to ICC and first phase of Elemental Unrest) were months (almost an year) apart - as pointed out many times (see above).
Heck, in fact, that paragraph didn't even say that Deathwing caused it. It said the Unrest preceded Deathwing's return, and Deathwing's return shattered Azeroth in process. That's nothing new and I don't think anyone argued against that. So... how is it the answer for the discussion at hand, then?