Is our prot pala in our guild underperforming?

[Deleted]

The only thing you need is a disc priest putting CoW and spamming bubbles on you during breath.

Maybe if you're 680 iLvl - it sure as shit wasn't the case at 660.

[Montoyal]

The only thing you need is a disc priest putting CoW and spamming bubbles on you during breath.

While that's pretty much true , that's completly beside the point since they don't have a disc priest and having glyphed DP is still better than unglyphed, especially when taking into account tanking the flesh-eater.

[sexybeast]

Maybe if you're 680 iLvl - it sure as shit wasn't the case at 660.

The 200k ish absorb would be great no matter what ilvl.

My first pull was at 660 ilvl, 1st kill was like 664. Yeah the externals made a massive difference but Im not sure if on our kill/progress pulls out disco knew about the CoW/bubble spam. All I know is if I have it now I loose like no HP whatsoever.

[gramz]

I have read something about it, that the combatlog doesnt register the skill proper or something like that.
I mean you can see in logs how many times it has been used. But doesnt show up under buffs or anything.

A little annoying but doable =)

there is a "workaround" to see exactly WHEN it was used as well.

If you select the GoAK (Players, paladin, prot paladin) under the player's tab, and then go to resources. Simply hover OVER the graph for say HP, and a line will pop up showing where it was used with a time stamp. This is the only way I've found to reliably tell when it was used

[Hekkipekki]

there is a "workaround" to see exactly WHEN it was used as well.

If you select the GoAK (Players, paladin, prot paladin) under the player's tab, and then go to resources. Simply hover OVER the graph for say HP, and a line will pop up showing where it was used with a time stamp. This is the only way I've found to reliably tell when it was used

Oh thank you =)

[Hekkipekki]

I have some more logs that I would appreciate a few other pair of eyes on.
I gave him a long list what he should improve at, what is your second view of him now?

Anything that has gotten better? Or are the basic rotation and cd handling still shitty?

Mythic Twin Ogron:
Kill = https://www.warcraftlogs.com/reports...aken&source=24
Wipe 1 = https://www.warcraftlogs.com/reports...aken&source=24
Wipe 2 = https://www.warcraftlogs.com/reports...9XT6V1#fight=3

Brackenspore Mythic:
Kill = https://www.warcraftlogs.com/reports...aken&source=24
Wipe 1 = https://www.warcraftlogs.com/reports...aken&source=24
Wipe 2 = https://www.warcraftlogs.com/reports...aken&source=24
Wipe 3 = https://www.warcraftlogs.com/reports...aken&source=24
Wipe 4 = https://www.warcraftlogs.com/reports...aken&source=24

[Montoyal]

https://www.warcraftlogs.com/reports...24true%2420925

As you can see, he didn't actually use DP on all the breaths he took, and actually ONLY ever used it when taking breath damage never to reduce the add damage. Given an unglyphed DP and Unbreakable spirit as a talent he can and he should basically use DP on all breaths, and just to keep it on sync to also use it when tanking the add while the other tank takes the breath. Given a 9 min duration fight he could have used DP close to 18 times.

His SS uptime seems lackluster still.

He didn't die to breath because of the disc priest. Yay for disc priest on brackenspore.

[Hekkipekki]

https://www.warcraftlogs.com/reports...24true%2420925

As you can see, he didn't actually use DP on all the breaths he took, and actually ONLY ever used it when taking breath damage never to reduce the add damage. Given an unglyphed DP and Unbreakable spirit as a talent he can and he should basically use DP on all breaths, and just to keep it on sync to also use it when tanking the add while the other tank takes the breath. Given a 9 min duration fight he could have used DP close to 18 times.

His SS uptime seems lackluster still.

He didn't die to breath because of the disc priest. Yay for disc priest on brackenspore.

How did you set up the filters for that report you linked?
Like for this fight - https://www.warcraftlogs.com/reports...TJcM6#fight=19

Is it possible to set it up so I see all of the bosses casts/attacks on the player and when he cast cooldowns/spells?