My guilds raid comp

[Liax]

http://raidcomp.mmo-champion.com/?c=...00000000000000

This is our current comp. We 2 heal most fights, with the ele shaman healing on fights we 2 heal.

We're a bit melee heavy, and it's recently came up about replacing the frost DK since he only shows up when he pleases, and when he is here, he's always the lowest dps. I'm trying to find a specific class to complete our comp. They wanna replace him with someone who's worse and another melee.

Suggestions on a class to replace him? Looking forward to your replies.

[Deleted]

Boomkin, then you can have melee haste for your 2 melee and have spell haste for the healers and casters + they are awesome.

[Minaah]

compentent Shadow Priest, or Boomkin, would get my votes.

[Liax]

I partially agree with that. However, finding a good one is the problem. Any other suggestions?

I can also point out, that we have one cloth wearer, however we got 3 leather wearers. I'm thinking Shadow priest is the way to go.

[Deleted]

A shadow priest would share gear with the mage but the boomkin would only share gear with the resto druid, so gearwise it's pretty much the same.

[Daytraders]

Shadowpriests are limited without a warlock. I'd get another frost DK or a lock.

[Deleted]

Shadowpriests are limited without a warlock. I'd get another frost DK or a lock.

Sad but true. I'd probably get a DK/boomkin/lock as well.

[Gliff]

S priest or boomkin. provide a great buff and 2 of the top dps classes.

[Deleted]

Assa rogue? You'd best be kidding. 3 melees is already too much and Assa rogue doesn't compete with combat.
Grab another ranged, preferably Demo lock or Moonkin. SP is fine too.

[Kodiene]

I'd go with lock or spriest

[Pikapika]

Definitely spriest.

[Stevoman]

Shadow priest or warlock.

Recommend the priest since they can be made to heal on the off chance you're missing healers one night.

[Pokty]

If you got a moonkin you would have 6 people on the vanquisher token which would be less than ideal.

[Liax]

Assa rogue? You'd best be kidding. 3 melees is already too much and Assa rogue doesn't compete with combat.
Grab another ranged, preferably Demo lock or Moonkin. SP is fine too.

The rogue is one of the top dps as assa. Pulls nearly 30k.

[Stevoman]

The rogue is one of the top dps as assa. Pulls nearly 30k.

This anecdotal evidence doesn't mean anything except that your raid's DPS is low...

[PHsname]

Shadowpriests are limited without a warlock. I'd get another frost DK or a lock.

Shadow Priests are still plenty strong without locks. They're still PLENTY strong.

S priest or boomkin. provide a great buff and 2 of the top dps classes.

They already have the buffs those two specs provide. Moonkin are also pretty bad if there's nothing to AoE.

Assa rogue? You'd best be kidding. 3 melees is already too much and Assa rogue doesn't compete with combat.
Grab another ranged, preferably Demo lock or Moonkin. SP is fine too.

A good Assassination Rogue will compete. Also from what I've seen, Assassination does better in p3 H Rag than Combat. That's all that matters.

The rogue is one of the top dps as assa. Pulls nearly 30k.

Anecdotal claim is anecdotal.