In fact it's not even on the 50% best games I've played. I played for like 6 hours and I just can't see the appeal in it. The combat is really shallow, feels like just a game of left mouse/right mouse button, making a first person melee game is not something good, plus when I change to third person, the controls are really awkward, you lose the control of your character until your animation finishes, that doesn't happen on first person. The menus are abominable for a PC version, I've never seen such a bad port from consoles. The puzzles are too simplistic, really simplistic, like seeing 3 statues with simbols on one wall and replicating them in another to open a door. The "bosses" that I fought, the dungeon spider and the skeleton on the same dungeon, can be so easily exploited that it's ridiculous
The most overrated game ever, in my opinion