Which raid of them all had the best TRASH?

[Larwood]

I was reading a thread on official forums, and it got me thinking about the whole raiding experience and how trash is an integral part, so which raid do you feel had the best trash?

Please try to base your vote on the trash only, don't all just vote Ulduar because it's your favouritest raid evar. 15 choices limit means I have to exclude a couple that I think people might have voted for (like ZA or BWL), but whatever.

[Joels]

Trial of the Crusader.

[rebecca191]

I guess I'll vote for ICC, there wasn't extreme amounts of trash and it wasn't too annoying.

[Anyankha]

There's a bunch of raids that have interesting trash, but I will have to go with firelands, just because of those epic spinning turtles destroying tanks and melee alike while we, range, play ping pong with them

[Rhoxx]

You could have just ignored the turtles the whole time.

[Junkkiller]

gruul's lair
something in its simplicity still charms me

[AQrunnr]

I voted other. ToC is my preference. No trash ;-)

[Larwood]

Was a tough choice but personally I went kara, it was all so varied and interesting but still not too much of it (except maybe leading up to moroes but I had fun killing all that stuff it was challenging).

[Rhoxx]

You forgot Blackwing Lair in the choices. The trash to the third boss was epic fail because of the slow substance that was shot out of the suppression poles that rogues needed to disarm.

[Serzy]

Ulduar with its oh so simple yet oh so hard for many trash mobs, and the encounter before Flame Leviathan... Oh and the bombs around Mimron, oh the joy and anger!

[Fetacheese]

It might have been a little too extensive (especially the library area between curator and shade), but the abstractness and coolness from Karazhan's trash can't be beat.

[Larwood]

You could have just ignored the turtles the whole time.

I don't understand people who ignore the turtles, or worse, pull them recklessly and wipe. They are quite a lot of fun once you know how they're meant to be done. :P

[Anyankha]

You could have just ignored the turtles the whole time.

Oh no, NEVER ignore the turtles if u want a massacre

[Larwood]

You forgot Blackwing Lair in the choices. The trash to the third boss was epic fail because of the slow substance that was shot out of the suppression poles that rogues needed to disarm.

Yeah that was the hardest one to cut, but there wasn't really enough trash in there for it to stand out.

[Tihr]

Surely whoever voted Firelands never played in TBC? Tempest Keep and SSC had far more interesting trash than anything we've seen recently. Sunwell trash was kinda fun, too.

[mistuhbull]

Trial of the Crusader

there is a reason it is called trash.

[Resentful]

Would probably be Karazhan personally.

[Slonato]

Trial of the Crusader

there is a reason it is called trash.

Exactly what I was going to say. Trash is simply there to waste are time, and I want no part in it.

Have trash respawns ever been a good thing?

[Larwood]

Trial of the Crusader

there is a reason it is called trash.

There's also a reason ToC is arguably the most hated raid of them all :P

---------- Post added 2012-02-28 at 11:26 AM ----------

Exactly what I was going to say. Trash is simply there to waste are time, and I want no part in it.

Have trash respawns ever been a good thing?

After 2 hours of wiping on a boss in a raid you don't want to leave because your friend is leading it :P

[Anyankha]

Surely whoever voted Firelands never played in TBC? Tempest Keep and SSC had far more interesting trash than anything we've seen recently. Sunwell trash was kinda fun, too.

I played BC, I remember those trash all too well. But throughout all my years of raiding, I don't think I ever cried out of laughter as the 1st time we pulled those turtles without knowing much about them, and seeing how our poor kitty and tanks went flying to their deaths. Healers running back, while 3 mages and a hunter were kiting ping-pong like, trying to survive and trying to also kill those turtles.
Too much epic fun.