Originally Posted by
eriseis
I think music is about what it makes us feel, period. If Justin Bieber makes you feel something, there's nothing wrong with that.
I think people get on a high horse regarding music:
1. Boo! People who do it for money suck! Um, even classical composers did it for teh moneh.
2. People don't write their own music! It's been centuries since the model of people interpreting others' music was established. Are plays less of an art if Shakespeare doesn't play his own plays? Does Swan Lake need to be danced and played by Tchaikovsky to be relevant?
3. Pop music sucks! Again, it's about entertainment, if pop music sucks, go listen to Mahler, not random bar band.
4. X is better singer/band/player than Y technique-wise! Even in classical music you find people who are amazing at their technique but carry no feeling. Music is about making you feel..