1. #1461
    Deleted
    With a 25k test (With my gear).

    Enginnering/Tailoring:
    Code:
    Runs = 25000
    DPS: Median    = 236827
    DPS: Mean      = 237479 +/- 64
    DPS: Range     = 205805 -- 298277
    Damage: Median = 106,9M
    Damage: Mean   = 106,9M +/- 656
    Damage: Range  = 103,5M -- 107,5M
    Time: Median   = 7,5m
    Time: Mean     = 7,5m +/- 120ms
    Time: Range    = 6,0m -- 8,7m


    Eng/BS
    Code:
    Runs = 25000
    DPS: Median    = 236643
    DPS: Mean      = 237321 +/- 65
    DPS: Range     = 201357 -- 293584
    Damage: Median = 106,8M
    Damage: Mean   = 106,9M +/- 774
    Damage: Range  = 105,4M -- 113,5M
    Time: Median   = 7,5m
    Time: Mean     = 7,5m +/- 121ms
    Time: Range    = 6,1m -- 8,8m


    Tailoring/BS
    Code:
    Runs = 25000
    DPS: Median    = 235228
    DPS: Mean      = 235916 +/- 64
    DPS: Range     = 203469 -- 288560
    Damage: Median = 106,2M
    Damage: Mean   = 106,2M +/- 698
    Damage: Range  = 102,6M -- 106,7M
    Time: Median   = 7,5m
    Time: Mean     = 7,5m +/- 120ms
    Time: Range    = 6,1m -- 8,7m


    Scribe/Enchanter:
    Code:
    Runs = 25000
    DPS: Median    = 234706
    DPS: Mean      = 235459 +/- 64
    DPS: Range     = 205533 -- 286261
    Damage: Median = 106,0M
    Damage: Mean   = 106,0M +/- 600
    Damage: Range  = 105,3M -- 108,6M
    Time: Median   = 7,5m
    Time: Mean     = 7,5m +/- 120ms
    Time: Range    = 6,2m -- 8,6m


    SOLO PROF

    Only engineer:
    Code:
    Runs = 25000
    DPS: Median    = 233878
    DPS: Mean      = 234594 +/- 64
    DPS: Range     = 204439 -- 287508
    Damage: Median = 105,6M
    Damage: Mean   = 105,7M +/- 770
    Damage: Range  = 102,9M -- 108,0M
    Time: Median   = 7,5m
    Time: Mean     = 7,5m +/- 120ms
    Time: Range    = 6,1m -- 8,6m


    Only BS:
    Code:
    Runs = 25000
    DPS: Median    = 232533
    DPS: Mean      = 233195 +/- 64
    DPS: Range     = 202219 -- 287352
    Damage: Median = 105,0M
    Damage: Mean   = 105,0M +/- 684
    Damage: Range  = 104,2M -- 111,6M
    Time: Median   = 7,5m
    Time: Mean     = 7,5m +/- 121ms
    Time: Range    = 6,1m -- 8,7m

    Only tailoring:
    Code:
    Runs = 25000
    DPS: Median    = 232483
    DPS: Mean      = 233157 +/- 63
    DPS: Range     = 201249 -- 284904
    Damage: Median = 105,0M
    Damage: Mean   = 105,0M +/- 635
    Damage: Range  = 103,9M -- 107,5M
    Time: Median   = 7,5m
    Time: Mean     = 7,5m +/- 119ms
    Time: Range    = 6,1m -- 8,7m


    Only enchanting:
    Code:
    Runs = 25000
    DPS: Median    = 232129
    DPS: Mean      = 232841 +/- 63
    DPS: Range     = 200748 -- 283370
    Damage: Median = 104,9M
    Damage: Mean   = 104,9M +/- 826
    Damage: Range  = 94,30M -- 107,2M
    Time: Median   = 7,5m
    Time: Mean     = 7,5m +/- 120ms
    Time: Range    = 6,2m -- 8,7m


    No prof:
    Code:
    Runs = 25000
    DPS: Median    = 229569
    DPS: Mean      = 230234 +/- 63
    DPS: Range     = 201345 -- 278693
    Damage: Median = 103,6M
    Damage: Mean   = 103,7M +/- 606
    Damage: Range  = 101,1M -- 104,3M
    Time: Median   = 7,5m
    Time: Mean     = 7,5m +/- 121ms
    Time: Range    = 6,2m -- 8,6m


    So to sum it up:

    Engineering Tailoring and BS stands out when it comes to professions, Engineering by alot because of it's syncing with TF, Tailoring because of the proc which is quite awkward but dose line up with most oftenly every other TF, And BS because of the option to pick 640 secondary stats instead of 320 primary stats (Whice JC, Enchanting, Scribe, LW Alcy only provides 320 base agility)

  2. #1462
    Quote Originally Posted by Etapicx View Post
    And BS because of the option to pick 640 secondary stats instead of 320 primary stats (Whice JC, Enchanting, Scribe, LW Alcy only provides 320 base agility)
    Probably won't matter once 5.4 hits, the Rune nerf makes gemming secondary stats not really a thing. Haven't tried in full heroic double upgraded gear yet though.


    Druid / Demon Hunter SimulationCraft Maintainer

  3. #1463
    Thank you for this. Currently I have jewelc rafting along with leather working. I get most of my gold from jewelcrafting, and so will only really be able to swap out one of the professions for now. So, I'm guessing leather working > Engineering. Even so, it is only something like a 3-4k dps upgrade.

  4. #1464
    I'd think twice before dropping leatherworking. Drums of speed can be pretty valuable.

  5. #1465
    Deleted
    As the poster above said, There is more to professions then just the stat bonus. Especially if you are like me struggling with gold only and only having one 90 toon :P

  6. #1466
    Quote Originally Posted by Etapicx View Post
    Talking about loot... Darkwood Spiritstaff TFHC woop woop.
    Lucky, my guild has yet to see a heroic TF weapon for feral and that's with 15 horridon and 4 lei shen kills. Feels awful to be the only dps in the 25m raiding group without a TF weapon.

  7. #1467
    Quote Originally Posted by Etapicx View Post
    Talking about loot... Darkwood Spiritstaff TFHC woop woop.
    "Growl Growl, Hiss, Growl" xd but grats nice to see you get some weapon luck for a change. I've yet to see even the normal/lfr version of that staff drop.

    Quote Originally Posted by Zer0xChan View Post
    Lucky, my guild has yet to see a heroic TF weapon for feral and that's with 15 horridon and 4 lei shen kills. Feels awful to be the only dps in the 25m raiding group without a TF weapon.
    I know that feeling, I've yet to see a heroic weapon drop...in my 25 as well-and we have a Brew Monk as the main tank so I always get the 2nd weapon anyway.

  8. #1468
    Deleted
    Looking at the Cactus program, the video in the guide and I'm still confused about how to reforge for it. Is there no clear step by step guide?

  9. #1469
    The Lightbringer Elunedra's Avatar
    15+ Year Old Account
    Join Date
    Jan 2009
    Location
    Netherlands
    Posts
    3,346
    why didnt you sim the dps of a leather worker ? skinning
    also RoR was nerfed? or do you mean the change in RPPM, will it still be BiS after nerf?
    TREE DURID IS 4 PEE

  10. #1470
    Deleted
    Quote Originally Posted by Zer0xChan View Post
    Lucky, my guild has yet to see a heroic TF weapon for feral and that's with 15 horridon and 4 lei shen kills. Feels awful to be the only dps in the 25m raiding group without a TF weapon.
    Don't feel so sad. Our group has yet to see horridon even drop a staff. Killing him on at least normal mode since week one. We haven't had a Lei Shen weapon drop either (guardian won on coin roll).

  11. #1471
    Quote Originally Posted by Themessiah View Post
    Thank you for this. Currently I have jewelc rafting along with leather working. I get most of my gold from jewelcrafting, and so will only really be able to swap out one of the professions for now. So, I'm guessing leather working > Engineering. Even so, it is only something like a 3-4k dps upgrade.
    I wouldn't even change it if you have it capped. I went from LW/Skinning to LW/Engi but not for min-maxing, it was because I wanted us to waste less time hearthing to repair and getting summoned back..

  12. #1472
    Warchief Redpanda's Avatar
    10+ Year Old Account
    Join Date
    Oct 2010
    Location
    Searching for the Old Gods
    Posts
    2,185
    you need to be a slacker cat like me and get it just to get synapse springs then stop right there and the only other skill ups are from fire spirits and not learn the boy schematics
    Last edited by Redpanda; 2013-08-12 at 11:30 PM.

  13. #1473
    Quote Originally Posted by Tarazet View Post
    I wouldn't even change it if you have it capped. I went from LW/Skinning to LW/Engi but not for min-maxing, it was because I wanted us to waste less time hearthing to repair and getting summoned back..
    That 3-4k dps upgrade may well put me above the lock in my guild on Lei Shen :P I'd pay the 15-20k or whatever it will cost just to watch him squirm lol!

  14. #1474
    Hey all, couple quick questions! I believe I read this here, but correct me if I'm wrong. I understand we clip a non-RoR Rip with a RoR Rip, right? And if so, is it worth clipping a RoR Rip with a RoR and TF Rip sub 25% for the snapshot + FB spamming? And what about clipping a RoR Rip with a TF+synapse springs one?

    And I'm really sorry if this has been answered elsewhere (I'm pretty sure I read this here- I just wanted to confirm) but when RoR procs, we spam Rake for CPs, correct?

    Anyway, thanks for reading, and I'm so sorry if these questions have been answered and I missed them!

  15. #1475
    Quote Originally Posted by aggixx View Post
    Probably won't matter once 5.4 hits, the Rune nerf makes gemming secondary stats not really a thing. Haven't tried in full heroic double upgraded gear yet though.
    What is the rune nerf ? i guess it will come, but i havnt seen anything yet...

    - - - Updated - - -

    Quote Originally Posted by Derpcat View Post
    Hey all, couple quick questions! I believe I read this here, but correct me if I'm wrong. I understand we clip a non-RoR Rip with a RoR Rip, right? And if so, is it worth clipping a RoR Rip with a RoR and TF Rip sub 25% for the snapshot + FB spamming? And what about clipping a RoR Rip with a TF+synapse springs one?

    And I'm really sorry if this has been answered elsewhere (I'm pretty sure I read this here- I just wanted to confirm) but when RoR procs, we spam Rake for CPs, correct?

    Anyway, thanks for reading, and I'm so sorry if these questions have been answered and I missed them!
    you will always clip a non ror rip with a ror one. No matter the % (maybee not sub 3% ofc). TF springs isnt enough to be better than RoR rip. however a fully stacked renetakis is better than ror rip. But around 20-30% try to plan around getting some really nasty rip up with pot DoC TF springs and either renetakis fully stacked or RoR or if lucky both.

    When ror procs you spam rake for combo points, but you should always try to come out with a DoC buffed rake when RoR ends. if you dont play DoC it doesnt matter.

    hope it answers your questions otherwise feel free to whisper me in game

  16. #1476
    Deleted
    What he means with the RoR nerf is the rppm change in 5.4 that will make multiple trinkets not "double dip" from haste, but since it strikes almost everything and the trinkets in next patch has the same model of not "double diping" RoR is still BiS it's just that the uptime is going to be changed :-) But since the uptime is hurt it means that the overall value of the trinket is lower and that means that we will most likely not gem with secondary stat, if not in end tier. And that means that BS will be as strong as the other "regular" primary professions (except Tailoring slightly and engineering)

    Changing subject a little bit!

    I just want to highlight that when 5.4 around the corner the guide will require and update. That i will do under the upcoming days after patch is live and probably some before. However the point of me posting this is that i do want ideas and feedback from as many as possible, so i can make the guide as great as possible for the feral community. If you don't want to post here please don't be afraid to send me a PM about it :-)
    Last edited by mmoc3782ac376e; 2013-08-14 at 10:31 AM.

  17. #1477
    Mentioning Catus on the front page could be a good idea, as could links to other websites that are of use to ferals, such as thefluiddruid. Moreover, for people starting out at a low item level, the rotation can be difficult merely due to a lack of crit and energy regen. Perhaps some advice for a more fluid rotation for those under an item level of, I don't know, 490(?), even if not optimal for dps could involve the prioritisation of crit and haste over mastery.

  18. #1478
    I couldn't recommend haste at lower gear levels, the return on it is just so negligible, you won't get any real noticeable energy regen out of it. I think you'll just have to make a tighter priority, reduced use of fb above 25% and such.

  19. #1479
    Quote Originally Posted by Themessiah View Post
    Perhaps some advice for a more fluid rotation for those under an item level of, I don't know, 490(?), even if not optimal for dps could involve the prioritisation of crit and haste over mastery.
    u just telled urself as it not good for dps why u should prioritisatize them?

  20. #1480
    Stood in the Fire Paloro's Avatar
    10+ Year Old Account
    Join Date
    Sep 2011
    Location
    Panama City Beach
    Posts
    376
    Quote Originally Posted by Zstr View Post
    u just telled urself as it not good for dps why u should prioritisatize them?
    If I'm reading this correctly (which was very hard btw), he is suggesting that mastery is still the top stat sub 490 itlvl but to smooth out the rotation, more of an emphasis on crit (and maybe a little more haste) would be beneficial.

    To me, mastery is just way to good of a stat to give up. 100% uptime on Rake and SR are really the key to beginners.

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •