This could be easily explained by the first seller making a mistake/typo while entering your data. Even something as simple as entering an incorrect middle initial can cause delays.
- - - Updated - - -
About 33000 firearms deaths annually.
Defensive firearms uses are somewhere between 65000 and 2.5 million depending on what study you want to believe. So really defensive gun usage is pretty much greater than firearm deaths by a good amount. Somewhere between twice as common to almost 100 times as common.
I even pulled the numbers from the same wiki site so you can't say I'm cherry picking data to get the best results from each data point.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gun_vi..._United_States