First of all, nice written post about
your opinion on warriors.
Im sure some veterans will counter each argument, im however no pvp'er so my comments may be wrong.
just 2 things i picked out for facts
Shieldwall does require a shield - reducing the dmg a warrior does drastically. you made it look like its just a 40% dmg reduction button
Second Wind - also stops when we are back at 35%. just apply more then ~10k dps to outdps the heal. (i made that sound easier then it is).
Thou shall not use this as an arguement.
Remember cataclysm, there was only 1 warrior in the top brackets at some point. overall it was the very very very least represented class above 2200.
When this was used as arguments, warriors were told off (putting it very nicely)