Let them go, its the girls fault she was looking too good, late at night, taunting them like this.
Long Term Detention
Short Stay in Prison
Nothing: Let them go
if it were me, id give them to the women in prison, let em have them. Or give the others a cloth incase they wanna save their country some money and let them hang themselves.
Problem is those people NEVER EXPECTED TO BE CAUGHT OR PUNISHED for rape and murder. Its time for things to change, and if you want things to change, sometimes it has to be taken into considerable measures
yes that is exactly what im saying. Im saying US has done some very very naughty things as well, just as bad as the rape case in India. so im not sure what you are trying to disagree with here.
read the comments below
most people feel the same. With such brutal acts, sometimes vengeance is the only way
All in all, in some circumstance they should be able to live, but as what India is facing, there's no room, no money, no point as they will at least get beaten to death in prison
Last edited by bigfootbigd; 2013-03-11 at 08:39 PM.
"I hate to advocate drugs, alcohol, violence, or insanity to anyone, but they've always worked for me." -Hunter S. Thompson
That example was just a succinct one, btw. There are plenty of more abstract examples of stuff that you can logically not support if you think that killing is always wrong, such as the police, or the military. Of course, those guys kill less people than would alternatively be killed... and so we see why killing sometimes is a good idea.
And I assure you, humanity is quite content to look itself in the mirror "without being disgusted after condoning the execution of sick individuals" - what would be disgusting would be the opposite.
“To who do you reward the right to decide which speech is harmful, or who is the harmful speaker? Or to determine in advance what are the harmful consequences going to be, that we know enough about in advance to prevent? [...] It may not be determined in advance what words are apt or inapt. No one has the knowledge that would be required to make that call.”
- Christopher Hitchens, 1949 - 2011
Regardless of whether or not a victim may die from this type of assault, the perpetrators deserve to be tried for rape and murder (attempted if the victim survives, which is not the case here) rather than just rape.
Quick recap of what took place according to updated reports:
Woman and her companion were taunted and assaulted, both beaten with a metal pipe. The male companion was tied up and gagged while the woman was taken to the back of the bus and raped repeatedly by each of these assailants. According to an article I read, medical reports revealed that she was raped with the metal pipe as well.
The assailants than tried to run her over with the bus, possibly to hide evidence of what they had done and make it look like a death resulting from an accident.
So far, there is little to no evidence to suggest that there was anything wrong with them that would affect and/or impair their temporary or permanent skills of judgement, i.e. they were of sound judgement and completely aware of what they were doing and intended it.
Verbal and physical assault, rape, torture, murder (some would argue attempted but....really cmon...), and all of these done in the most gruesome way imaginable. The type of punishment these people really deserve would be classified as 'cruel and unusual punishment' by any legal standards.
Given that scenario, the punishment they most qualify for that falls within the confines of a civilized legal system is the death penalty without a doubt.