So, I totalled it up and came up with the 5 games that received the most votes, and I decided to leave the final round up in the form of a poll to see who wins the GotY awards.
Your nominees are Pokemon Black and White 2: 9 votes
Torchlight 2: 7 votes
The Walking Dead: 7 votes
Guild Wars 2: 12 votes
Planetside 2: 6 votes