I am in 25 man guild and I would like to stay in one
I am in 10 man guild and I would like to stay in one
I am in 25 man guild and I would like to be in 10 man guild
I am in 10 man guild and I would like to be in 25 man guild
Btw i tend to agree, about the abandonation of the dual size aproach.
I dont see multiple size dungeons, why the raid should be stretched or bended to squeeze just a few or every body in?
There is a another poll about preffered size in the first page of raids and dungeons subforum with options scaling from 10 to 40.
I dont discredit this one, but i believe that the hole "leave things as they are" from the 10 man lovers side vs "25 are dying we need to incendivise them" from 25 man lovers is leading nowhere.
If you missed to see it, raiding has shrunk as an hole. And with it the game.
My two cents anyway. The benefit you get from keeping those 2 sizes in the game is vastly insignificant combared to the damage they re causing to it.
WTB 15 man raid answer as well! the developers keep mentioning that they would like to try this, but often say that they dont want to interfere with 10m and 25m groups that guilds have set in place, forcing them to either scrounge for more players, or make cuts to their core group. my answer to this is - test it out on raid finder. that doesnt interfere with any guild core groups and would be a nice way to test out what many to believe is the "sweet spot" for a raid group number. gogo 15m raids!!
Over 400 voters now, still need around 100 more for decent sample. The more the better ofc .
Well, I don't think you are going to get a good sample... Just look at the number that are in 10/25. If this was representative, there won't be any problem. At all. Half and half 10 and 25, everyone happy.
In the end like I said earlier I can give even 10% of error margine which is a huge, huge one and we will have some rough picture.
Last edited by Radalek; 2013-01-08 at 09:50 PM.
Raided both formats and both have up and down sides. Currently raiding 10H progress.
-Easier to find required number of competent people
-More personal and higher responsibility
-Less loot and a lot of dependence on loot RNG (2 items dropping out of possible 15-25 on loot table - GL seeing what you want)
-Less epic feeling
-Feels like a real raid, something large scale
-Less dependent on RNG with loot, gets more loot per person
-Hard to get required number of competent players
-Much higher risk of random stuff happening (someone fails a mechanic, DCs etc)
Both formats are good and fun. I raid 10s now cos its damn near impossible to find 25 late night heroic-capable people on my server. Also I don't have really good PC to handle 25s at acceptable graphics level.
I'm in a 10 man and I'm quite happy with it.
I think ideally I'd prefer to be in a 25 man, but I only want to raid about two nights a week, and I have some specific times I can't raid (like wednesday night) which most 25s raid on. There are very few 25s that would work for me, and I'm currently in a guild that is pretty much perfect for me. So I'm perfectly content to be in a 10 man.
I think I'd prefer 25s because I raided a lot in Classic/TBC, but only recently got back into the raiding game after a long time out. 25/40 man is what I'm used to and the 10s feel small. I sort of miss the huge number of people I had in my guild in Classic and TBC. But I'm with a great group of people now, so it's all good.
More than 450 voters now, need 50 more to reach the goal from the start. The more the better ofc .
I tried both 10m and 25m and I do prefer 25m but I care most about the social aspect of the guild rather than raid-size, I would never stay in a 25m guild if I'm not having fun even if that would mean to switch to 10m again.
I like 10s - the smaller size means that you've got more chance to draw out shy people, and those are the ones with the most creative solutions and surprising points of view. It's too easy to get lost in a group of 25.
what about ppl who like both equally? ur poll needs more options.
i voted 25 but i am on a 10player guild
would have prefered an 15p version vote
Was in a 25man guild but heavy populated, left server and joined up too a medium pop 10 man guild and im loving it.
You are lying! I never hit you! YOU ARE TEARING ME APART, LISA!
There should be two more options:
Currently 25m, happy to be either 10 or 25
Currently 10m, happy to be either 10 or 25
I really don't mind, I've been in both and they're each good in their own ways.
Just because it's really difficult to do doesn't mean some people wouldn't still enjoy it more.
So some % from the current standing in the poll.
Of the people who voted:
35% of 10 man raiders would rather be raiding 25s.
13.5% of 25 man raiders would rather be raiding 10s.
72% of raiders are happy with their current raid size.