What if monsters were real and all the members of the gender you like would be monsters? Would you date one?
I mean real monsters, like vampires and ghouls, werewolves and ghosts, mummies and mermaids (tritons too), centaurs and minotaurs, zombies and wraiths, skeletons and yetis, big feet and cat people, reptilians and cyclopses, demons and gorgons, ogres, orcs and trolls etc.
No monsters are too human, so there are none just ladies with a simple tail or something. Only true creatures considered monsters in stories and they'd always be in their monster looks, so the werewolves would always be wolf-men/women, never humans.
So, would you date a monster miss/mister if you liked them? Would you even accept to be friends with them?
Edit: they'd be as regular humans in terms of personalities, so some (a minority, like 5%) are murderous savages, but most are not. Though you still have to take their powers in mind, gorgons can turn you to stone by looking at you for example.