You don't see that tend on other bosses?:P
http://raidbots.com/epeenbot/eu/laug...ull/%C3%A9ddy/
On bosses with adds / multiple targets is where I think I tend to do better lol, with the exception of Tortos due to not using some cheesy kite tactic for infinite deep wounds damage and Horridon this week due to letting our DK tank solo tank the fight = P
I think you are underestimating how much crit affects our damage and will be even more so than live with the ultimatum changes as well
Most of those logs are done with 20% crit, going up to something like 40% crit and with the trinkets you will be seeing catastrophic levels of DPS from Prot Warriors
I'm not quite sure if you could reach a 1-1 rotation as pally next tier, it might be doable under lust but I still think the filler will be required... even so I think you will see the DPS between the two classes as fairly equal, especially with the change to Alabaster Shield / Various others
- - - Updated - - -
I would agree with this but it would be dumbing down the class in a certain way that I quite enjoy playing and that's maximising your Shield Block uptime for fights
I do however agree that there needs to be some sort of compensation for Shield Barrier, possibly something along the lines of 0.75 second per 10 rage spent to make sure that its on the same sort of level as Shield Block in terms of Rage / Uptime