So last night we sharded http://www.wowhead.com/item=104308/a...d-soaked-robes. I'm running http://www.wowhead.com/item=103802 and it is very much in the realms of 'could be an upgrade but very very unlikely to be'. (I need to keep 4 piece but can use 1 slot for offspec whilst I build to T16 4 pc) Whereas our shadowpriest is running the Haste/Mastery i543 chest from Hc ToT.
Now I know it drops an 'ideal' stat of his, haste but surely it is a dps increase for him over his current chest.
The loot system of the guild I am in normally works well but it really annoys me to see stuff getting sharded when it is an upgrade. Am I wrong ? How would other guilds handle this. We use dkp btw with a min bid of 200 and generally get 200/raid.