So we are going to start on heroic Siegecrafter this week, and taking the average amount of wipes which guilds are spending on the boss, i would love to be prepared for it, and what strategy we should start off with. We got our heroic Thok kill last week 1 tanking 2 healing the fight, so i am open to any strategy that can help us get a kill.
We have the possibility of staying pretty far away from the belt if we choose to bring double hunter so they can take the belt alone, but i rather run with main team minus the frost dk. That or the zerg tactic with the hunter instead of the resto shaman. But honestly I'm getting very torn looking at how differently it can be done. I guess what I'm looking for is the best way to start progress off with, which should suit our classes best.
Bring the 2 hunters it'll ease up your belt by a lot (instead of the frost DK), that way you'll have a very stable belt group with minimal fails regardless of what tactic you use. I'm not too familiar with the zerg tactic but we handled it by just doing it normally and the boss died around the 5 minute marker (2 healers, 2 tanks, 2 hunters, rest dps of all sort but primarily ranged)
We actually had a very similar group make up as yours. The fight will be pure hell, actually sit the ret for the hunter. There will be deaths all over the place and the more people you have to battle rez the better as 1 person being dead will more than likely cause a wipe. Frost DK is actually quite good on the belt if needed as most can solo one with just Empowered Runeweapon. But yeah, bring 2 hunters and have them do the belts with the help of the WW.
I'm also in the process of cutting up our kill video, PM me if you want a link to it.
Agree with one of the posts here, use both your hunters and sit the frost dk, as he's undergeared anyway. You have a good group for the mine tactic, so I'd suggest doing that rather than the one healer zerg tactic. More room for errors. You also have plenty of slows/cc for the mines with your group.