Niether of them have had that much of an offensive line, but Tomlinson in my opinion isn't quite the same as Peterson, I would take All Day over LT, because despite the fact that he is the only person on his team worth a damn on offense, some teams still cannot prevent him fro getting 100+ yards on them. LT at least something resembling a supporting cast most of the time in SD with Gates / Jackson, even if Norv Turner is a joke.