Originally Posted by
Warriorsarri
By that logic one should also gem and enchant for Str rather than crit as Fury and Arms? For Fury Crit is about 20-50% stronger than Str Per Point, so if 1str gives 1dps, 1crit gives 1.2-1.5dps. This is the case until you reach 53% crit, at which point you've reached the "soft crit cap" where Bloodthirst has a 100% chance to crit, guaranteeing an enrage proc. after we reach this crit goes down to be about the same str as Str, and mastery climbs ahead and becomes our strongest stat*.
For Arms Crit is less damage per point than Str, it's at about 1dps str - 0.6-0.9dps crit ratio.
*Crit is still really strong, I'd recommend that you do a Reforge Plot if you want to know for sure which one is the strongest for you.