We are currently stuck on Butcher HC, it seems like we got enough DPS, as our best try was 214k left on the boss, but i feel what stopping us from killing it is random tank deaths, and its usually the bear that gets killed 1st, then the paladin falls stright after. Logs are above.
The Druid is taking a fair bit more from Heavy Handed. Are they stacking close enough? It could be double hitting him. Once he dies, it'll start double hitting the Paladin too.
We were stuck on Butcher HC the first week too. Had like 15 wipes on it after one-shotting kargath. What we choose to do was, kill twins (took us 2 pulls) then tectus. After that we went back to butcher and one-shot him
We already killed the twins aswell, did some pulls on Brackenspore, but the same tank problem wipes us there. If we dont get Butcher down today, we will try Tectus
Your Bear tank should be using Guardian of Elune instead of Pulverize. The chance of 100% dodging some of the attacks will make up for the 15% dmg loss. Especially during berserk phase. Your dps is kind of low as well.
EDIT: Also not sure if WarL shows or not but it looks like your bear tank never casted savage defense or survival instincts the entire fight. Correct me if I'm wrong
We have 2 melee groups and we switch the first time at 4 stacks of gushing wounds. After that 3 stacks. Thats how we managed to kill him. Use heroism/bloodlust at 30% when he enrages and after he charged so you've full potential of your heroism/bloodlust.
Hope you are informed well enough to get that Christmas head of him