Multi/Spirit ring simming higher then crit/vers?

[RawrTiffany]

This is my armory: http://us.battle.net/wow/en/characte.../Kate/advanced

I'm comparing: http://www.wowhead.com/item=113947/e...loop&bonus=567 and http://www.wowhead.com/item=113901/s...band&bonus=567

Six-Eyed band sims 5 hps higher (WITH the 50 crit enchant on my current ring, so the ring+50crit vs just the six-eyed band, and it still sims 5 hps higher). I presume thats because of the spirit which is BiS on rings/trinkets/necks.

But should i be taking a spirit ring and dropping one of my trinkets for say the goren int/crit one?

So like drop iron spike chew toy, for the goren one? Not sure. The 2 trinkets i have are BiS, but the goren was not included in sims. Referring to: http://fullspectrumholypally.files.w...uper-sheet.png

So would our BiS trinkets at this gear level be http://www.wowhead.com/item=119194/g...tory&bonus=567 and http://www.wowhead.com/item=113986/a...lave&bonus=567

Any thoughts?

[Deleted]

No. The goren trinket will proc randomly and the crit will be wasted. Keep your chew toy.

[otip]

I haven't read anything by Holybouch since BRF came out, but at the release of Highmaul his priority lists grossly over valued spirit. With your current gear (spirit) level I don't see why you couldn't drop Autoclave for Goren straight up. The proc on Goren is RNG, and that's annoying, but so is Autoclave's: a crit proc is much better than a haste proc though. For the couple mana intense fights you could swap back in your Autoclave if you're uncomfortable with your mana. Granted you probably aren't going to get a Goren trinket (does it even proc from heals anymore?) As for the Six-Eyed Band, I wouldn't even consider it unless you have sub 1k spirit, and even then I would be looking to replace it ASAP. Those stats are dead weight.

[Reica]

I have 4 trinkets that I just swap between depending on the upcoming encounter. Those being the Chew Toy, the Goren Repository and two older Highmaul trinkets (Shards of Nothing and Mark of Rapid Replication).

If I need lots of spirit on either very long or very intense fights, I use the Chew Toy and the Mark. If it's a fight where mana doesn't matter I run with the Repository and the Shards. Other combinations are possible as well on more average fights, again, depending on the situation.

Got to love 45%+ crit when the Repository procs..

Last night on our HC Kromag kill, my Co-Holy Paladin cursed at me for having around 17% more crits on Holy Light than he did, while I only have 2% more crit on my gear than he does.

[CloudedInSanity]

You're BiS trinkets will be Goren and Chew Toy imo. You don't need a static spirit trinket, Chew Toy is far superior to Autoclave in almost every way. It nets you around 15-20% less mana, depending on procs, and also gives you static int which is far better then a haste proc could ever be.

Goren is 2nd because again, we don't need spirit, and it has a ton of raw intellect on it. The proc can happen at a bad time, but from my experiences so far in MBRF almost all fights are just a constant amount of damage, not bursty.

Keep yourself around 1000 Spirit, healing intelligently (don't waste mana or do large overheals) and ooming will not be an issue.