Claw or satyr as unholy? (Neck enchant)

[SkagenRora]

Hey.

The sites i usally check both say different one. So now i'm just wondering, Which is the best one or are them both good?

- - - Updated - - -

Come on. Noone knows? I really need help here to decide which one to buy

[Deleted]

Hey.

The sites i usally check both say different one. So now i'm just wondering, Which is the best one or are them both good?

- - - Updated - - -

Come on. Noone knows? I really need help here to decide which one to buy

I just went with claw for now, since it's also useful for tanking 5 mans and both satyr and distant army are apparently bugging out sometimes.

That being said, Satyr sims the highest (roughly 3k dps more than claw) and distant army is 300dps behind satyr. However, distant army is supposed to be AoE so it could be the best overall choice.

[Gr1mdark]

Hey.

The sites i usally check both say different one. So now i'm just wondering, Which is the best one or are them both good?

- - - Updated - - -

Come on. Noone knows? I really need help here to decide which one to buy

I've went for satyr.
As all the resources like icyV told me to.
Didn't test anythink. We'll see tomorrow how it turns out in the raid

[ChronoSul]

If you are using Castigator then use claw but if you are using clawing shadows use satyr

[Supercowmaster]

Using Hidden satyr, I am 847 and the proc is criting for 100k, while my brother's enhance shaman is hitting for like 250k at 844ilvl. Not sure how that enchant is scaling but i think im gonna swap to claw (using castigator)

[Baddok21]

Satyr is better for single target but does not scale (attack does fire dmg)

Claw is better for Cleave/AoE and will eventually outscale Satyr on Single target, as 1.6% haste/crit benefits you, your ghoul, your army, your Gargoyle, rune regen, castigator etc etc

[Deleted]

Go distant army

It is only like 300 dps behind satyr, but does way more aoe, and thus in the end is an overall better enchant.

Dont use claw

[Deleted]

Go distant army

It is only like 300 dps behind satyr, but does way more aoe, and thus in the end is an overall better enchant.

Dont use claw

Does distant army actually do aoe? I've heard that it's a single target damage proc, but haven't tested it myself in-game.