Still have my Rhok'shalla/Frenzystrike on my Hunter, BOO YAH, hope they never bring them back, WUAHAHAHAHHAHA!
There are certain ones that should be. Example: Icebane plate set. There are parts of the set that are still obtainable, yet half of the set doesn't exist anymore. Problem is there are no pieces to substitute them with. Either bring back pieces to complete sets that are incomplete without them, or make new items that can fill their spot.
Things like corrupted ashbringer should not be added back in.. they are not a part of a set that is still available. That is my opinion
Metal on Metal O.O \m/
I'd really hate it if they would do that. I already think it's dumb that tier 3 appears only on the BMAH. It's such a lazy fucking way of reimplementing old armor, and all the rich tryhards immediately bid goldcap on it, so most people have no chance of ever getting it.
If they're gonna reimplement old armor, make them quest rewards. Or rare dungeon drops for all I care. But don't just toss them on the BMAH so only the rich kids can get them.
Oh I was throwing in a sarcastic thing because I remember when this whole thing was like don't remake Benediction or Rhok'delar etc but when Quel'serrar happened no one actually cared. So I'm of the mindset for the stuff like Benediction or Chromatic Sword rerelease that.
For stuff like Atiesh... the only way that would fly Is by the proper release of Timewalking raid content/zones. That were world events. So 1 month out of the year Naxx timewalking might have a chance of that made sense. Still bad RNG soooo ya.
But that's as far as I would go with that.
Sure I have, and I have six of them. About 600k total across all of my characters. But that doesn't buy you anything off the BMAH, does it? And with 1.4M, you're done after buying one goldcapped item. I'm talking about the people with multitudes of millions of gold.
- - - Updated - - -
But why through the BMAH? We can still get every single other tier set, and they're still rare because droprate is RNG. Why not do the same for tier 3? Why chuck them on the AH so only the richest can get them? They're not even rare, it's just a matter of camping the BMAH and bidding goldcap.
And believe me, in Legion those rare items will still be capped almost immediately. The only difference is the number of people able to get them will shrink even more.
Yea, tier 2 is so rare.. It's on BMAH because naxx40 was removed and that's where retired items go most of the time if they come back, just because you are not able to get something doesn't mean it's a bad system. If tier 3 dropped from bwl noone would care about the sets.
Also you don't seem to understand the basics of how BMAH supply works, the gold cap has no effect on how many is able to get it, BMAH will still have the same amount of T3 pieces as always, so the exact same amount of people will be able to get it as before. If you are not one of them, tough shit.
I really don't care if they add old stuff back. But then I don't really feel the need to brag about having something others don't. I have my special snowflake stuff because I wanted it when I got it. The fact that some of it is no longer available just makes me feel bad for new people who never got the chance to try.
I always hope they would remake archaeology to give old removed items from finds to reward their skins rather then the current system of just giving you crap till you proc a rare.