Originally Posted by
VigilantRose
I don't believe you should run any kind of 'Renew build'. What I'm pointing out is that Benediction is almost strictly better than Circle of Healing - it generates a significantly greater amount of surplus healing at a much lower cost. You don't need other talents or gearing to augment it - the talent just stands alone as a great talent.
The question is how it stacks up against Apotheosis. Personally, I find Apotheosis just doesn't 'fit' for most content. It's absolutely the best talent for dps purposes, but that's not usually the issue. For Serenity/Sanctify, I end up wondering "how often do I need to cast these spells slightly more often?" - and the answer is usually "not often". If Prayer of Mending is actually bouncing, it outperforms Apotheosis/Serenity in terms of healing/efficiency. Apotheosis/Sanctify can potentially be better, but by the time you start really benefitting from Apotheosis the problem you're trying to address is generally over and you're back into low output healing mode. So you really need to find 30 sec periods of sustained AE damage (which do exist) and have them be prevalent enough to overcome Benediction's basic advantage.