simcraft

[T1berius]

Why does the fury profile have the damned seed pod on the 865 trinket? Are they trolling?

It's clearly a tanking trinket and does way less dps than the current 865 bis which is the unstable arcano crystal.


I read somewhere that people could just upload whatever they wanted to the profiles, is that really the case? Who the hell thought that would be a good idea?


http://imgur.com/a/8yTsR

[booi]

Historically, Collision has done an excellent job with the dps profiles. The last update to the fury one was 18 hours ago and doesn't use the trinket you are referring to.

https://github.com/simulationcraft/s...Fury_T19M.simc

If the live version of simcraft isn't using this yet, try to copy and paste the profile above and see how your results vary.

[T1berius]

http://www.simulationcraft.org/reports/Raid_T19H.html

Shows ravaged seed pod for fury

[booi]

Can you link the gear portion of your profile? As far as I can tell the trinket you're referring to was never in the apl

[T1berius]

https://github.com/simulationcraft/s...rior_T19H.simc


it's right here

trinket1=ravaged_seed_pod,id=139320,bonus_id=1805
trinket2=natures_call,id=139334,bonus_id=1805

both are worse than the 865 arcano crystal

Are these used because 865 is wargforged? Even then, ursocs paw should be simulating much higher than the pod, so should an 840 pvp stat stick, and even the base 860 arcano

[booi]

It doesn't look like the gear has changed since the original profile creation.

https://i.imgur.com/zHL0n3x.png

If just tweet collision, can or message him on this forum if there's a huge disparity between the trinkets.

[T1berius]

oh, it was probably just generated from the original profile that didn't really have changes?

It's odd because so many people like to point to the sims the day of as if they're bis (had someone argue with me that the seed pod was bis because it was on simcraft)

[booi]

You're absolutely correct.

Not sure how the fury community is, bit on the prot end we have a huge problem where someone runs some and concludes"these are the start weights", but they never link the apl they used or that of the boss.

On the whole when someone links stat weights, we as a community need to ask for a link to the generating SIM

- - - Updated - - -

You could even submit a ticket to simc. I believe collision does a good job of reviewing them

[Xanthan]

The H profiles are largely incomplete. You could just take the P profile and change all the bonus IDs to 1805 if you want a decent H gear list, or just put in whatever gear you feel like.