While true, I think that mentality is simply attributed to the fact that there are SO many games that meet the persons specific criteria/ expectations that there's no need for them to branch out and try these "lesser" games (in their opinion).
For example, I don't have anything against "indie games" or smaller games that used retro graphics styles (Undertale) but I just can't get myself to play one for long because I just really enjoy more current and graphically intense visuals. FFVI is one of my all time favorite games (I know it's not indie, just an example) but I just can't play it for that long because the graphics coupled with the old school control scheme don't provide a compelling gaming experience for me in today's sea of current gen games.