Talents(in most cases):
Consecration if there is always more than 3 enemies.
Execution Sentence pure single target. (If you have the cape you will ALWAYS pick Final Verdict)
Final Verdict mixed encounter (this may out preform Execution Sentence, you will need to simulate your character because this is largely depends on your stat combination)
Zeal if you have 4 set, or 2-3 enemies (This may pull ahead of Fires in single target, once again you will need to simulate your character)
Fires if you are single target and do not have 4 set
Greater Judgement if there are always 4 or more enemies
Nothing else has changed, Divine Hammers falls too far behind in single target for high level mythic plus content and should only be used in 1-8 Mythic plus dungeons and raid scenarios of 3 or more enemies at all times.
Stats:
Haste soft cap is 20% but 30% is the break point for more Holy Power spenders in Crusade.
Critical strike is about equal to versatility
Mastery
Bis relic:
Increasing Crusade time. Please note this is worth 24 item levels and is stronger than all other relics. The reason for this is in 2.5 seconds you are able to unloaded one or two more holy power spenders. This is several times stronger than a slight percentage increase to Templar's Verdict or Divine Storm.
Thank you Snackfeat for presenting this table
Quick trinket mention:
Swarming Plaguehive is no longer strong for Retribution paladin due to the removal of blessing of might. Here is an ordered list of our best trinkets.
1. Convergence of Fates
2. Draught of Souls
3. Eye of Command (second place with chest piece)
4. Kil'jaeden's Burning Wish
5. Faulty Countermeassure
6. Unstable Arcanocrystal
Bis Legendary items:
1. Chains of Thrayn- This is the best legendary item currently available to us, the 20% increased damage during Avenging Wrath/Crusade is much stronger than the capes 12% buff.
2. Whisper of the Nathrezim- This is the second strongest legendary item and falls behind Chains of Thrayn slightly. This is still a very strong legendary however, Chains increase to our burst window has a much larger impact.
3. Ashes to Dust- The only downside of this legendary is that you only get this burst window every 30 seconds and sometimes you might hold of Wake of Ashes, for a few seconds, in order to deal with a large group of enemies.
4. Liadrin's Fury Unleashed- After the nerfs this ring is still a strong legendary item however, it just can not compare to the top three. It will not compete with any of them.
5. Prydaz- The reason why Prydaz is rated higher than Sephuz is because of the other items available. With three stats, and two of them being BIS for Retribution, Prydaz is much stronger than any neck currently available.
6. Sephuz- The change to Sephuz's ability is very helpful. It also provides amazing stats to us however, Sephuz does not out compete all other rings available to us the same extent as Prydaz out competes other neck pieces.
Please note, the new legendary trinket is not worth taking due to the fact that more than two other trinkets available to us out compete this legendary item.
This information can also be found on Icy-veins and is supported from simming several retribution paladins at 880+ numerous times.