Strikes me as the most accurate. I play 90% of my mythic with guild tank and healer anyway, usually have a very accurate idea of what they can handle. It's the pug tanks that are usually painfully slow and quite clueless on occassion.
- - - Updated - - -
That has to be the most meaningless argument ever. There's also a reason everyone can get satchels in LFR, I got one as dps yesterday. I play tank as well this expansion, just not healer yet. As tank I'll pull as much and as fast as I can handle, but if we end up wipeing I don't say "fuck these other 4 people in a non-renewable instance", but rather I try to adjust and finish the instance as painlessly as possible. It just irks me that he and many other tanks, not so much healers this time around, seem to think they aren't as expendable as the next guy.