Which faction makes the most irrational decisions?

[TheramoreIsTheBomb]

Which faction makes the most irrational decisions in Warcraft? In my opinion, its the Alliance.

[Dangg]

In my opinion it's the Horde.
Fantastic discussion.

[RoutinelyWorgen]

From my point of view it's the Horde.

[Lorgar Aurelian]

horde .

[Radaney]

Mists of Pandaria says it's the Horde.

Horde put Garrosh in power leading to Civil War.

Alliance didn't dismantle the Horde.

Pretty much end of 'discussion'.

[Lorgar Aurelian]

Mists of Pandaria says it's the Horde.

Horde put Garrosh in power leading to Civil War.

Alliance didn't dismantle the Horde.

Pretty much end of 'discussion'.

the horde didn't put garrosh in power thrall did almost all of the horde leaders turned on him instantly.

[Zandalarian Paladin]

They're both terrible.

Very, very terrible.

[Radaney]

the horde didn't put garrosh in power thrall did almost all of the horde leaders turned on him instantly.

Thrall was warchief of the Horde and made a decision for the Horde.

[Zelk]

Blizzard, definitely

[Heffladin]

Blizzard, definitely

Garrosh went from "we dont bomb civilians, we have honor" to doing just that, setting forth a story most people wish hadn't happened. Aethas let Garry get the doomsday device instead of standing up to him, and I doubt even the true horde had the capacity to fight Quel'thalas. Rhen we have Jainas reaction, while not completely irrational, bit out of character, (garrosh syndrome?). Genn is irrational, thats pretty much his defining character trait. Tyrande is irrational because... she's been given terrible dialogue that resonates poorly in my opinion to her past. So I'd give horde the slight edge here.

[MoanaLisa]

The faction at Irvine HQ that writes this stuff.

That said, however many sides there are in a long war both make plenty of dumb and irrational decisions seen in retrospect.

[Luckx]

Even Orcs and Undead vary and pretty different there is good Undead/Forsaken like Meryl Felstorm,Alonsus Foal, Leonid Bartholomew the Revered, Lillian Voss and many others.

There is Orcs like Garrosh and there is Orcs like Eitrigg who became Tirion Fordring best friend and saved his life despite that Tirion attacked him first and tryed to kill Eitrigg at start.

And there is Night Elves who summoned Burning Legion into the universe, and humans like Scarlet Crusade,Plagueland Necromancers,Lich King Scourge,Syndicate.

And there is Taurens like Feltotem and Grimtotem tribe who poisoned Garrosh weapon which lead to Cairne death.

[FelPlague]

And immediately Cairne and Vol'jin disagreed. Meanwhile when Varian decided not to push to disband the Horde (or at least make a truce with the Alliance at the very least claiming something out of the entire mess) he had all the Alliance with him except for Jaina.

i love the cherry picking here
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RWTdz54duxo
notice how he makes a truce with the horde?
yeah you ignored that part didnt ya

[Deleted]

Alliance especially in Legion

[FelPlague]

. . . did you actually read my comment? He asked for nothing to give them that truce. That's irrational.

he asked for them to uphold honour unlike garrosh

[Dalheim]

Thrall was warchief of the Horde and made a decision for the Horde.

And the majority of the Horde would've probably voiced their disapproval had they known before-hand.

[Polarthief]

They're both terrible.

Very, very terrible.

Definitely this.

"OMG THE DEMONS ARE INVADING AND KILLING EVERYONE!"

[Greymane]: "FUCK THAT UNDEAD BITCH SHE PROBABLY DID THIS"

It's more specific people are just stupid and making dumb choices.

[Gelannerai]

Meh, depends on which faction they want holding the idiot ball whenever they need a flimsy excuse to keep the tired, hackneyed faction war going.

[Blackspiral]

Based on recent events and expansions. I would put them pretty much even.

Granted, this is more blaming Blizz Lore and writing then anything else.

[Deleted]

Which faction makes the most irrational decisions in Warcraft? In my opinion, its the Alliance.

What kind of question is this? The Alliance even has an intelligence service and they still fail to retrieve the correct information, lol.

- - - Updated - - -

Definitely this.

"OMG THE DEMONS ARE INVADING AND KILLING EVERYONE!"

[Greymane]: "FUCK THAT UNDEAD BITCH SHE PROBABLY DID THIS"

It's more specific people are just stupid and making dumb choices.

I'd question any leader of anything if his decision making is terrible.