I can't really be bothered arguing either but I do take exception to your "bad tank" accusation. I geared for maximum effectiveness for the content I was doing. Unfortunately I no longer have a copy of the spreadsheet by Arielle on
http://www.theincbear.com/ that I used back then with my own values plugged in, but I can assure you that it showed effective health values for agility and stamina that were similar enough for agility to be a winner overall. I was not doing 25hc Icecrown. I did have relatively low health compared to some bears, but more than enough for the content I was doing. I looked through some old screenshots and saw myself unbuffed in Dalaran in June 2010 with 42k health. I can remember a tank we pugged for ICC25 dying in a single gcd pulling the first trash pack in the raid. They barely scratched me. He was a stam stacker with crap gear who had 50% more health than me.