Yes. The problem is that people are lazy fucks who don't want to do anything. For this to happen you need to be 940+ in the first place which means above average M+ farming with additional pieces of gear from here and there.
Right now it's "I don't have time and willingness to do anything or wipe few days on a boss, but I'm outraged that people don't want to invite me into pugs with a queue full of 999+ ilvl people with cutting edge achievements".
- - - Updated - - -
Well, if you exclude guilds who don't raid heroic (or just don't raid at all) then you will have 95% guild clearing H Kiljaeden.
FOMO: "Fear Of Missing Out", also commonly known as people with a mental issue of managing time and activities, many expecting others to fit into their schedule so they don't miss out on things to come. If FOMO becomes a problem for you, do seek help, it can be a very unhealthy lifestyle..
No I'm good at everything in this game. That was what that list was. The point is that he says you should have to join a guild and raid with them first to get aotc, and for every single raid this expansion I haven't had to do that and gotten aotc just fine. Have like 3 attempts on HC KJ before I joined a group and 1 shot it. Admittedly 943 ilvl helps with that but that's what I get for doing well in all the things that are less time consuming but give better rewards than HC tomb (in the case of PvP it's better rewards, lul).
Think I've wiped more to KJ in raid finder than on HC, it's a joke.
Why group leaders still ask for linking things is beyond me as they are so easy to fake. Just use MythicPlusHelper and screen your applicants (hint: the name doesn't do the add-on justice, perfectly suitable for raids).
As to why people ask for previous experience: because they can. You are strangers to each other, so people will use whatever signal they can get to up their chances of having a smooth run.
The advice you've probably heard numerous times before: join a guild. It is the escape from anonymity. Many guilds will organize fun/alt runs where a few of the guild on mains support gearing up the rest. Will this get you AotC early? No, as for that you need to prove your worth and get into the core raid team. Will it get you there eventually? Most certainly.
And as others have said: your PUG, your rules. If you don't like what others demand, make your own. I understand the anxiety. But there is always a cost, right? I bet you will be as selective as all the others making groups though ;-)
But I am raiding? Whenever I like as a matter of fact, I just roll into the LFG tool and find a curve group and one shot the raid??
- - - Updated - - -
It must be considering there are people saying unless you can join a guild and raid you shouldn't raid
Who has linked cutting edge and don't get invited because its not specifically aotc. This guy.
<SPK> US 8th Xavius Mythic - US 10th Helya Mythic - US 8th Gul'dan Mythic - US 9th Kil'jaeden Mythic - US 12th Argus Mythic
7/7M Emerald Nightmare - 3/3M Trial of Valor - 10/10M Nighthold - 9/9M Tomb of Sargeras - 11/11M Antorus the Burning Throne
World first heroic Gul'dan. Almost Wildstar hardcore status.
Boi (plural: bois) is a term used within LGBT and butch and femme communities to refer to a person's sexual or gender identities. ... In lesbian communities, there is an increasing acceptance of variant gender expression, as well as allowing people to identify as a boi. There is no assumptions in this house.
<SPK> US 8th Xavius Mythic - US 10th Helya Mythic - US 8th Gul'dan Mythic - US 9th Kil'jaeden Mythic - US 12th Argus Mythic
7/7M Emerald Nightmare - 3/3M Trial of Valor - 10/10M Nighthold - 9/9M Tomb of Sargeras - 11/11M Antorus the Burning Throne
World first heroic Gul'dan. Almost Wildstar hardcore status.
This is by far the biggest problem I have with WoW these days and the reason I quit for 3 months recently.
Ignorant people think that an achievement equals skill. Personally I can't guildraid, cause I can't play regular hours. So pugging is my only option. And I'm fine just farming HC raids. But pre-legion I was a Mythic hardcore raider. It's insulting, after all my Cutting Edges and previous raid accomplishments, to not get invited for a HC boss.
No, I'm not at Methods level, never was. But I always cleared all Mythic content before the next raid came out. So to think I could not handle a HC boss is a kick in the nuts.
Hell, I am sure even Method players, who had many world firsts, would be declined without curve if they turned casual and for some reason decided to Pug...
Man, lots of people, me included, learn a boss just by watching a video of it or reading about it. Lots of people have previous Mythic raiding experience, which makes HC bosses, even Kiljaeden a joke. You don't need 940 or a curve to do it if you are a good raider. And previous raid accomplishments should make up for and even mean a lot more than a KJ achiv.
If someone link impressive Mythic raid experience, they are gonna learn KJ in 1 try anyway EVEN if they never even seen a video. Most likely, not even mess up at all regardless of first time.
And WHY. Please tell me, WHY, would 8/9 bosses matter? Those 8 bosses are NOT KJ so what use do you have of them at KJ?
I'm sorry, but your posts come across as someone who has never raided mythic (old heroic) ever. I'll address the bolded points one by one.
Watching a video doesn't mean you "know the fight" all it knows is you have some basis of an idea on the fight and know things to watch out for. Watching the fight once on youtube does not mean you are going to go in and perform all the mechanics perfectly.
Previous experience, while good doesn't mean you know the content. Yeah, you may have the skill but first time on a boss is still first time on a boss. You're going to make mistakes and it's going to take some time to learn the fight well enough to not make mistakes.
Previous boss kills matter because if I am a pug leader putting a group together and some guy with no achievement and no experience whatsoever says they're good, I am not going to believe them. I have no gauge of their skill, I'd have to take their word for it. At least if they had previous boss kills leading up to the final boss that the group is working on, you could reasonably assume they have experience with the content and have probably seen the fight at least a few times.
you are just missing the point. If you in a guild, why would you pug. If the leader is such a tard that all they are looking for is a carry themselves and they do not want to put any work into selecting his team then fuck him. He deserves people using fake chieves.
The way I pick my pugs, if I do need them, is solely on ilvl. I actually decline anyone who gives me an achieve and message them for being a moron for linking on toons the achievement is not for. Like really? You linked a chieve for a hunter but you're telling me you are ready to tank it on your under geared alt? Fuck off. I normally go for a -10/+5 of my ilvl. Someone who should be geared enough with out being so over geared for it that they are bored. If it doesn't work out then I bad mouth their transmog and kick.