Originally Posted by
MrFiddleswitch
OK. I'll bite. What "Quality" did Timeless Isle, Tanaan Jungle, and/or Isle of Quel'Danas have that is better than what Argus is offering? And let's limit this to the content that is currently out right now - as the Dungeon and Raid are not. What features did Timeless, Tanaan, and Quel'Danas offer that Argus does not?
I am looking at both quality and quantity and I find 7.3 to be one of the highest quality patches this game has ever seen - the Isle of Thunder being the only other one I may prefer over it (and that's simply because I really enjoyed how the daily quest hubs and story advancing took place there).
It has brought new gameplay features in the invasion points - While these are simplified versions of the pre-launch event - the pre-launch event was received by the community as one of the best new features that WoW has had in years, and these give something quick and fun to do that makes the world feel alive since there are usually a good number of players working together to complete the event.
It has brought multiple new enemy types, new models, new environmental model/doodads, new textures and all of them are high quality and interesting (the void corrupted creatures and environments in particular are amazing)
It has brought solid story content - something very few "island patches" have ever been able to bring - and certainly the highest quality of content than any of the previous end patches. The quality of the cut scenes in particular are fantastic considering this is just a patch.
It has brought a wide variety in environments, each with their own unique feel - Mac'aree being an open area steeped in history and unique environmental models and textures (void, ancient Eredar Structures, etc.) Krokuun being a constricting area with tight narrow passages that the Argussian use to hide from the legion and the Xenedar crash site with plenty of nooks and crannies to explore and a huge open area that serves as the front of the battle between the Legion and the Army of the Light at the Xenedar crash site, and then finally the Antoran Wastes with their fel pools, massive structures, floating citedals and dangerous, elite only areas. Sure, these last two use environmental models from Broken Shore and throughout the Expansion, but this is no different than Tanaan Jungle, Quel'danas, and Timeless Isle - all of which used nothing but re-used environmental assets and enemies from their respective expansions - 7.3 at least brings new enemies/models to these zones. At least with Argus, we get one fully unique area with all new environmental models, and massive new features like the Xenedar, The Fel Core, and the massive Antoran Citadel at the far west of the Antoran Wastes.
While most of the "rares" are not particularly interesting, this is no different than the rares in Tanaan or Timeless Isle. The only difference being that these are a bit more accessible (difficulty wise) if there are not a large number of people around. Not sure if this is a good or bad things and I will admit that I wish they something akin to Hu'lon or the Dread Pirate Ship - but the Greater Invasions seem to fill this gap. I do like the few "summonable" only enemies that require gathering specific quest items before you can bring out the rare.
I cannot really speak for the World Bosses since we have only seen one so far, but as a World boss, she was quite interesting - the Mind Control ability in particular is something we only usually see inside a raid, so I found it quite fun in a less organized environment. Certainly on par with 4 Celestial world bosses.
I'm sorry, i'm just not seeing where similar "Island Patches" brought quality content vs. 7.3 All I see is 7.3 doing a lot of things that other island patches did not (story, new models, new environmental models and textures, new gameplay features), and doing what those island patches did do the same or better (rares, world quests vs. daily quests vs. endless grind vs. meter fillers)
I would certainly love to hear your side of it though - something more detailed than "You are wrong" would be fantastic!