Originally Posted by
Pandemona
Wow, where do I begin proving you wrong?
First off,
I never said that warriors were "unable" to tank any of the current content. I said that they are the "worst" of the tanking classes. You telling me that plenty of people still use a warrior to MT does not state any reasons why these such people might do so, as I have laid out a number of reason why you would not use a warrior to MT.
"Warriors have high health pools, and a number of ways to mitigate dmg", yea sure...high in what respect? Perhaps compared to a mage, but certainly not compared to any of the other tanking classes with equal gear. And with avoidance/mitigation. Death Knights have way more avoidance, Pallys have way more shield block, and Druids have way more armor....so GG.
I never said warrior's cant dps. But frankly, the Fury tree is destroyed and we must now use an even more RnG spec to attempt to dps. And currently, warriors are the least DPS on bosses in the PTR. I am not just referring to the patch notes, which any person that understands basic math can take a 10% nerf to overall dmg....factor in rage loss...and come up with a good estimate at how this nerf destroys all utility of the Fury tree, but I have logged and tested these issues on the PTR...so GG again.
"Warriors bring way more utility than rogues" Currently on the PTR, a good combat rogue will do 500 to 1k more dps single target than an Arms warrior...1k - 1.5k more than fury self buffed. Combat rogues provide the same raid physical dmg buff as arms warriors so...GG. Every raid has 2 paladins these days, so there is no need for Battle Shout b/c of Bless of Might...again GG. Feral Druids, who are better tanks and better DPS currently ont he PTR, provide the 5% static crit buff as well as the "bleed dmg" buff...GG. So you might bring 1 warrior to sunder, but oops...rogues can expose armor...so I guess 1 warrior to use shattering throw with BL.
"Fury warriors can emergency tank", frankly you are an idiot. Zerk stance = +10% base dmg. That makes crits hit you for around 220% the base dmg...that is a 1 shot. Fury warriors have almost 0 avoidance, and around 12-14k armor ....which wont matter much if you are crit. You have never seen a fury warrior tank a boss in dps gear...not even for a few seconds...GG.
Yea, the 76 sec Sarth did have 4 fury warriors...the the class in first was a Death Knight...with 6.2k DPS. And a lot of the done in that encounter is spill over AOE, from WW... again GG. I'm not complaining, just saying...people who complain that Fury Warriors do too much dmg are bad players.
The Volley doing 9k is a slight exaggeration. The point is...in clearing trash...there are hunters who top meters with 95% of their dmg being from volley...no reason to bitch about Fury Warriors current DPS. And why you chose to comment about hunters as opposed to the outlandish DK, S Priest, Warlock aoe capabilities...baffles me.
I think in conclusion, please don't speak on a subject unless you know what you are talking about...and can support it.