Keepers kill order?

[Glencar]

From your experience, in which order should a progressing guild be killing Keepers in Ulduar? Please rate from easiest to hardest.
Thanks

[Nitrak]

Rating from easiest to hardest, idd imagine youdd like to step it up like that. (Though i did not do it in that order, but after ive experienced all of the encounters)

10 man:

Thorim
Hodir
Freya
Mimiron

25 man:

Hodir
Freya
Thorim
Mimiron

From my experience anyway

[Loster]

Depends on your group a bit. Good healers = hodir easy. Anyway this is what I have found.

Thorim.
Hodir.
Freya.
Mimiron.

[Nitrak]

Depends on your group a bit. Good healers = hodir easy. Anyway this is what I have found.

Thorim.
Hodir.
Freya.
Mimiron.

Refering to 10/25 man?

[Ryuuji]

We kinds just follow the circle(Except Mimiron is last)
Hodir, Freya, Thorim, Mimiron.

[Hunterian]

We do : Hodir, Thorim, Freya , Mirmiron .
I dont know why, it's been like that since we first got them down.

Difficultywise for our group from easiest to hardest:

Thorim, Freya, Hodir, Mirmiron


That would be 25 man.

[Retovia]

10 man I would say:

Thorim
Hodir
Freya
Mimiron

25 I would go with:
Hodir
Freya
Thorim
Mimiron

[xebtria]

25 man:
hodir, freya, mimiron, thorim.

mimiron is way easier, at least for us.

10 man... doesn't matter. they are all easy as shit. and yes, we do it with 25man gear. why? because we can.

[Eleidess]

10man:

Hodir
Thorim
Freya
Mimiron

25man:

Hodir
Thorim
Freya
Mimiron

You must do this way, or blizzard will send u a whisper.

[kriS411]

Hodir
Thorim
Freya
Mimiron

both versions

[Iradain]

10 man:

Thorim
Hodir
Freya
Mimiron

25 man:

Hodir
Freya
Thorim
Mimiron

From my experience anyway

Same for me

[Glencar]

Thanks everyone for your help.

If I do the math by awarding points (from 1 to 4 ) to each of the Keepers based on your recommendations, Hodir comes out the easiest with Thorim and Freya neck to neck one step further and Mimiron the clear number 4 (hardest).

1. Hodir (14 pts)
2. Thorim (22 pts)
3. Freya (25 pts)
4. Mimiron (39 pts)

[ecnarongi]

This depends on where your strengths lie.

For us when we were heavy melee dps, Hodir was a nightmare. Thorim was hard us too pre-gauntlet add nerf b/c of our lopsided melee dps. When we balanced out the ranged dps and melee dps then it became a game of healers keeping everyone alive on Mimiron.

Freya is an absolute joke without any elders up. we one shotted her the very first attempt we got to her.
Hodir is easy once you understand the usefullness of the NPC buffs, plus which NPCs to free and which ones to neglect.
Thorim is a tank fight.
Mimiron is a healer fight with a touch of positioning.

easiest - hardest
Freya
Hodir
Thorim
Mimiron

[Deleted]

Easiest fight order for us has been :

Hodir
Freya
Thorim
Mimiron

But we still do

Hodir
Thorim
Freya
Mimiron

in that order.. And in 25man to be more precise

[davesurfer]

10 man I would say:

Thorim
Hodir
Freya
Mimiron

That's what we do

[Sanguissa]

From our painfull progression of thorim 25:

Hodir (some healing and this fight is too trivial)
Freya (big better)
Thorim (we had some serious poblems on this)
Mimrion (well, mimrion on 25)


But...we spend more time on thorim 25 than on mimrion 25 progress.

Because we progressed mimrion in 10man, its one of the fights when 10man greatly helps you I think.

[GAfo]

Imo:

Thorim
Hodir
Freya
Mimiron

The first 3 are almost equal anyway just think about what you have in guild:

Thorim: huge melee aoe/ranged coordination
Hodir: healing/movement
Freya: Coordination/movement

You can choose the progress looking at what you slack at, surely mimiron is one step harder then the rest.