It shows him wearing both, my feral druid buddy and I put out a mutiny in the guild saying that its bullshit that they think him having both trinkets is even fair, and ontop of that would be better served with him than giving the two top dps (yes my rogue and his feral druid out dps this warrior and we both have no grim toll or mjolnir runestone) without the armor pen trinkets, the trinket. I'm not sure how much it would have increased my dps but I'm sure it would be a lot more noticable than him trying to proc both trinkets over time.
I posted this here so I can get the opinion on other dps warriors on if they think thats as stupid as I do or if I'm just being a cry baby, as I think thats some logical mistake on the warriors part, as the guy doign the loot was a tank and apparently didnt know about armor pen, and didnt know the warrior had a grim toll cause he linked his greatness card to be the replaced trinket. I think I've made this as clear as I can and hope I didnt confuse anyone. If the warrior had had no grim toll and got the trinket I wouldnt have minded because yes he is a raider and I'm an initiate but I dont think rank/loot council should apply when it visually is the same trinket as grim toll is and doesnt make sense when comes to sustained dps.