my point is that normal people who are gearing up their pally will not have access to cloth/mail, unless for some reason their shamans/cloth wearers do not want the drops. Obviously i don't just wear all plate for the sake of plate, as a matter of fact, my current gloves are cloth.
I do have enlightened judgements in my personal build, obviously you skipped it. but then again, it's not a top priority talent IMO. the gem thing is being editted, someone already brought it up