Shadows Edge, Bryntroll and JB - which ones to use? :(

[mortejn]

Just picked up Shadows Edge today and have been spending the last our trying to figure out which ones to use?
The three weapons i have; Shadows Edge, Bryntroll and Justicebringer (not the heroic one >_<)

Which one should i put where? MH/OH? Going mental soon, really have no idea.

My armory; http://eu.wowarmory.com/character-sh...lyon&n=Mortejn

Thanks,
Mort

[Freedom]

The proc rate of you offhand weapon is shit, maybe Bryn MH Shadow's Edge OH? As weird as that sounds.

Landsoul's says this setup is best apparently, esp factoring in that 245 JB has 1 socket where Bryntroll has 2.

[Nixreborn]

If JB was heroic it would be
Shadows Edge MH
Justicebring OH


but i see your predicament. Byrntroll losses a lot of it's effectiveness in the OH, but it feels like a loss putting Shadow's Edge in the OH. Simple answer is to run em through a spreadsheet. but im at work, so im worthless.

It's Either
Byrntroll MH
Shadow's Edge OH
or
Shadow's Edge MH
Justicebringer OH

best answer .... Get a Cryptmaker. Shadow's Edge MH / Cryptmaker OH ... BIS

[RPZip]

It depends on your gearing level, but typically it's Bryn MH, Shadow's Edge OH. If you're pushing for the hard ArP cap the non-heroic Justicebringer OH/Shadow's Edge MH may be better, but that'd be dependent on a lot of variables.

[Strafir]

[Mod Edit]

[mortejn]

[Mod Edit]

Im sorry for asking, i wont be posting here anymore.

[Strafir]

crap, mods got mad.
anyway, sorry for sounding agressive but I just got worked up lol

[Sondremac]

Well, I'm currently using Shadows Edge MH DBB (Horde Equaliant to JB)

Going for the hardcap, or well. I am at the hardcap, 98% is almost eh?

I'm getting a better result with 245 DBB than Bryn Troll. OH
And remmeber the 3.7 speed on Shadow's Edge is SWEEET compared to the 3.40 on BT

[Zhumla]

Well if you even want Bryntroll to even be effective you should have it in your MH or else it will be crap. So like the rest said stick with: Bryntroll > MH, Shadow > OH, putting Brynn in OH will just make it a total waste.

gl

[kopasetic]

After spreadsheeting it (Landsoul)


Bryntroll MH
Shadow's Edge OH

Max dps you can get out of the combination until you get Cryptmaker, then Shadow's Edge MH/ Cryptmaker OH