Cho'gall-C'thun

[Dark Side]

Okay, so until now i didnt beleive in Cho'gall as a lore charactor, that was changed by reading wowiki(my main source of info). And there it said "Cho'gall began the resurrection of his new master - the Old God C'Thun. This deformed the ogre's body which became monstrous and with features similar to his master's." and i thought that mabey what we fought in AQ wasnt C'thun,but just Cho'gall pretending to be C'thun (im unaware of the time period of his actions). However for those beleiveing that Cho'gall is currently ressurection C'thun are wrong, he is dead, Me'dan killed him with Ateish.

This being said, would it be a plausable theory?

[Anguish]

We killed cthun. Not chogall "yet". Chogall rezzing his master is after the inital killing.

[Surfd]

We killed cthun. Not chogall "yet". Chogall rezzing his master is after the inital killing.

Anyone who thinks we "killed" Cthun really does not understand how old gods work.

I mean, honestly, if the freakin TITANS themselves could not Kill the old gods (for fear of destroying the planet) what makes you think a group of 40 random heroes is going to do much more then inconvenience them?

[Anguish]

Anyone who thinks we "killed" Cthun really does not understand how old gods work.

We "killed" his body, we don't know exactly how to permanently end one is my understanding.

[sscavenger]

We "killed" his body, we don't know exactly how to permanently end one is my understanding.

Actually we do, it would just end up killing the planet in the process. Like a parasite the old gods have attached themselves to the vital organs of Azeroth.

[Freedom]

No - these events occurred while the Alliance and Horde were distracted by events in Northrend (Scourge, Malygos and otherwise) if I remember the smatterings of comics/wowwiki I have read correctly.

Destroying the planet - minor inconvenience, just fly away on a repaired Exodar!

[sscavenger]

No - these events occurred while the Alliance and Horde were distracted by events in Northrend (Scourge, Malygos and otherwise) if I remember the smatterings of comics/wowwiki I have read correctly.

Destroying the planet - minor inconvenience, just fly away on a repaired Exodar!

Oooh sorry, the repaired Exodar is draeni only. Lesser races not allowed.

[Simbert]

Well, as if you would not crash into the next island with your giant flying ship. I mean, islands are totally a major obstacle when trying to fly around, those things are everywhere. It is totally not a sign of total incompetence to ram one with your Spaceship.

[Juggynaut]

Oooh sorry, the repaired Exodar is draeni only. Lesser races not allowed.

Seeing as how the Draenai have crashed every single freakin' ship they ever piloted, I'd rather ride on a rocket built and driven by goblins, tyvm.

[Chonkers]

Also, consider the fact that (http://www.wowwiki.com/File:Cho%27ga...sformation.jpg) doesn't depict him as looking like C'thun. Again, sharing features sure, but we would have been able to tell the difference.

[Dark Side]

once agin i will remind you, you can not kill the body or soul of a old god,their tenticals are too deep in the core of azeroth, and killing their body would in turn kill the tenticles and in turn destroy azeroth, it hasnt happened and wont.

i figured out the chronology, C'thun is traped under AQ->We defeat him and drive his eye into the ground,not killing him->Cho'gall gets trapped there->Cho'gall gets killed by Med'an

[Nalnik]

As I remember it, the problem the Titans had was simply they were too powerful. Their method was blast everything with nukes, type of deal. Something like that would destroy the planet, yes.

It's never been said, however, if us mere mortals were to band together and go after the vital parts of the Old Gods like a surgical laser and kill them without destroying their physical bodies, what effect that would have.

I love the whole "The Titans couldn't do it, so we can't" bit because it deals with everything on a planetary, macroscopic scale and not the individual, microscopic scale.

That said, I agree that we probably cannot ever truly kill them.

[Elementium]

Some fun info.. as of WoW number 25... [Spoiler] Cho"gall is dead and garona is going twilight hammer huntin'"

[Haven]

Okay, so until now i didnt beleive in Cho'gall as a lore charactor, that was changed by reading wowiki(my main source of info). And there it said "Cho'gall began the resurrection of his new master - the Old God C'Thun. This deformed the ogre's body which became monstrous and with features similar to his master's." and i thought that mabey what we fought in AQ wasnt C'thun,but just Cho'gall pretending to be C'thun (im unaware of the time period of his actions). However for those beleiveing that Cho'gall is currently ressurection C'thun are wrong, he is dead, Me'dan killed him with Ateish.

This being said, would it be a plausable theory?

Yes. But we killed C'thun on accident when he was pretending to be Hogger in a perfect illusion.