Difficulty Order of 25 HC ICC bosses.

[ewhenn]

Going to try to keep this as shor as I can...

My questions only pertains to 25 man heroic ICC bosses.

For those of you that have done some ICC 25 heroics, in what order would you rank the difficulty of the bosses, easiest to hardest?

[WarriorGuides]

generally the order they come in.

[dannzi]

generally the order they come in.

yes, cause lady deathwhisper is easier then gunship ?

[Icthelight]

Hardest to easiest on fight Difficulty by mechanics
1. Lk
2. All the other bosses are hard? Thats news...
...
...
...
...
..
...
1232574371. Gunship

[WarriorGuides]

yes, cause lady deathwhisper is easier then gunship ?

shhh............ its...............hard............LOL :-X :-X :-X

[ewhenn]

Hardest to easiest on fight Difficulty by mechanics
1. Lk
2. All the other bosses are hard? Thats news...
...
...
...
...
..
...
1232574371. Gunship

Link your Heroic 25 man clear. thanks.

[hybris]

gunship
marrowgar
rotface
dreamwalker
blood princes
blood queen
saurfang
deathwhisper
sindragosa
putricide
lich king

roughly

[Mojojojo]

Easiest to Hardest:

Gunship > Marrowgar > Rotface > Princes > Valithria > Bloodqueen > Saufang > Festergut > Sindragosa > Deathwhisper > Putricide > Lich King

Just IMO. Sindragosa is easier than Deathwhisper, but because of the limited attempts mechanic is makes it harder(take 8-9 healers and its gets easier)

[Deleted]

gunship
marrowgar
rotface
dreamwalker
blood princes
blood queen
saurfang
deathwhisper
sindragosa
putricide
lich king

roughly

This, however i'd place Saurfang higher then Deathwhisper. Had more troubles with Saurfang.. IMO its more gearcheck, where Deathwhisper is more of.. communicate.

[Dethaele]

12. Gunship
11. Marrowgar
10. Rotface
9. Valithria Dreamwalker
8. Princes
7. Blood Queen Lana'thel
6. Saurfang
6. Festergut
4. Sindragosa
3. Professor Putricide
3. Lady Deathwhisper (PP and LDW both suck, but honestly PP isn't that hard if you think logically about and have the dps to do the transition phases.)
1. Lich King

I tied bosses that are kinda equal but require different skill sets. Saurfang preICC buff was a pain but with the new buff isn't really any harder than Festergut. Lady DW is all about dodging the non-targettable ghosts and PP is about managing several smaller things that add up to confusion. Both are equally easy to wipe on due to one mistake with ghosts or any of the easier to avoid mechanics on PP.

[Xe4ro]

I would rely on wowprogress numbers ^^"

Which are:

H: Lord Marrowgar (25): 1358
H: Lady Deathwhisper (25): 428
H: Gunship Battle (25): 1358
H: Deathbringer Saurfang (25): 697
H: Festergut (25): 652
H: Rotface (25): 1131
H: Professor Putricide (25): 122
H: Blood Prince Council (25): 948
H: Blood-Queen Lana'thel (25): 746
H: Valithria Dreamwalker (25): 748
H: Sindragosa (25): 193
H: The Lich King (25): 0

So in an Order of Kills

- Lord Marrowgar
- Gunship
- Rotface
- Blood Prince Council
- Valithria Dreamwalker
- Blood-Queen Lana'thel
- Deathbringer Saurfang
- Festergut
- Lady Deathwhisper
- Sindragosa
- Professor Putricide
aaand The Lich King

[Antik]

LK
LDW
PP
The rest are about equal
BQL
Sindragosa

[Lady Mormont]

Gunship - its retardedly ez if u can do normal mode u can do hardmode lawlz

Marrowgar - Slightly mor difficult cuz bonestorm actually hurts and he casts spike during bonestorm

Rotface - Vile Gas

Princes - coordination check, not really hard

Saurfang/fester/BQL - Same difficulty, all 3 are huge dps checks, if u can do one u can do all 3

Thats all ive done personally from what i understand the rest of bosses go like this:

Dreamwalker - Adds have more HP hit hard, etc. Dreamwalker takes dmg during the fight too

Deathwhisper - P2 kills us

Sindragosa - Havent attempted yet

Putriced - Havent attempted yet

LK

[fizyx]

According to WoWProgress.com:

Marrowgar: 1359 guilds
Deathwhisper: 428 guilds
Gunship: 1359 guilds
Saurfang: 697 guilds
Festergut: 652 guilds
Rotface: 1132 guilds
Blood Princes: 948 guilds
Dreamwalker: 748 guilds
Blood Queen: 746 guilds
Sindragosa: 193 guilds
Professor: 122 guilds

We can reorganize this from most downed to least downed, and then even split them into groups of what appears to be pretty closely related difficulty (although Sindragosa's numbers may be low. It's said to be an easier fight than the numbers say.)

Marrowgar: 1359 guilds
Gunship: 1359 guilds

Rotface: 1132 guilds
Blood Princes: 948 guilds

Dreamwalker: 748 guilds
Blood Queen: 746 guilds
Saurfang: 697 guilds
Festergut: 652 guilds

Deathwhisper: 428 guilds


Sindragosa: 193 guilds
Professor: 122 guilds

My only caveat here is that Gunship is by far the easiest, and I have no idea why no one has yet to pass up Marrowgar to at least get the heroic loot of it at the end of the week. Possibly because if you can kill LK, you should be able to kill Marrowgar HM with very little trouble.

EDIT: God damn it, Xe4ro beat me too it while I was typing this all up :<

[zeo]

IMO coming from a 9/12 HC experience I'd say from the easiest to hardest:

Gunship
Marrowgar
Rotface
Blood Princes
Valithria
Festergut
BQL
Saurfang / LDW
Sindragosa

[Grundy]

1 shotting Marrowgar is not unusual, but the adds on Deathwhisper take huge leap in difficulty.

[Jon]

Imo

1. LK
2. Sindragosa
3. Putricide
4. Deathwhisper
5. Saurfang

..

6. BQL
..

..

The rest are a lot easier.

[redrage]

I'd say roughly the order they where released how ever move gunship to easiest and dreamwalker isn't too bad if you got the group make up.

[Gobber]

Deathwhisper is far harder than people give credit for. You actually have to avoid the ghosts for once (no you can't just run a bit...still get hit then run back and think your doing it right). Combined with 3 MCs, more powerful adds...creates a very tough fight

[Amandil]

Saurfang/fester/BQL - Same difficulty, all 3 are huge dps checks, if u can do one u can do all 3

Is 25m a lot different than 10m? Saurfang we come close to the berserk. BQL we lost 2 dps half way though and still killed her. Festergut was closer, but we still 1 shot him the first time without really knowing what we wanted to do about the goo.