Best ICC10 Raid setup

[Beiter]

What would be the best 10man raid setup and why?

[Modez]

Most fights grant preference of 3 ranged over 3 melee.

My personal setup, which is 11/12 10 man Hard mode was build around buff maximization.

Forst/Blood DK tank
Prot Pally/Warrior

Destro lock
Moonkin
Ele Shammy
Rogue
Blood/Frost DK

Holy Pally
Disc Priest (that goes shadow)
Resto Druid

[Calon]

Tanks:
Protection Paladin
Frost DK

DPS:
Feral Druid
MM Hunter
Surv Hunter
Arcane Mage
Demo Warlock
Ele Shammy (that goes resto when needed)

Healers:
Holy/Dis Priest
Resto Druid

This is the makeup I run for 10's, it works nicely.

[Traejun]

Protection Paladin
Frost DK
MM Hunter
Arcane Mage
Retribution Paladin
Elemental Shaman [Can be Boomkin]
Mut. Rogue
Holy Paladin
Disc. Priest
Resto Druid [Can be Shaman]

[Ormula]

Most fights grant preference of 3 ranged over 3 melee.

My personal setup, which is 11/12 10 man Hard mode was build around buff maximization.

Forst/Blood DK tank
Prot Pally/Warrior

Destro lock
Moonkin
Ele Shammy
Rogue
Blood/Frost DK

Holy Pally
Disc Priest (that goes shadow)
Resto Druid

This is pretty good, and what my guild almost runs. If I had completely control, I'd say prot pally > Warrior, have the DK tank be blood and the DPS be frost. This setup IMO is one of the best.

[ThePocketNinja]

My ten man group (10/12 HM) runs...

Prot Warrior
Prot Pally
Resto Druid
Resto Shaman
Disco Priest
Combat Rogue (me)
Ret Pally
Ele Shaman
Arcane Mage
MM Hunter

We just got together as a group a few weeks ago, got LK down ten days ago, and have gone 10/12 in the six hours following that. We're stuck on H-Sindragoa right now with something stupid always wiping us in P3. Usually a healer with unchained, a healer tombed, and another healer set to be tombed... get's us every time.

[RevvRevv]

We use the following set up

Tanks;
Prot warrior
Prot warrior

Melee;
Unholy Dk
Muti Rogue
Enhance Shaman

Ranged;
Shadow priest
MM hunter

Healers;
Resto shammy
Resto druid
Holy Pala

[waddlez]

1 of each class

for epicness

spec as necessary

[Keosen]

1) Prot Pala
2) Prot Warr
3) Holy Pala
4) Disc Priest
5) Resto Shaman
6) Balance Druid
7) Shadowpriest
8) Warlock
9) Rogue
10) MM Hunter

[Richmond]

Tanks

Prot Warr
Druid (Me, can go resto)

Healers

HPriest (Can go Disc)
HPala (Can go Ret)
RShaman (Can go Enh)

DPS

Unholy DK (Has DW Frost DPS and a pretty decent tank set, useful for princes)
Warlock (Various specs)
Boomkin (Can go tank)
Rogue
Hunter (This guy has 7 Chars at 80, 5 of which can raid at ICC 25 level, he can bring almost anything)

We run pretty smoothly, but we really miss a mage in our setup

[Deleted]

8) Warlock

Warlocks are Cool

[Jenerena]

Well this is what we run with and it works good:

Tanks

Prot Warrior
Feral Druid

DPS

Demo lock
Boomkin
MM hunter
Ret pally
Combat Rogue

Healers

Resto shaman
Disct Priest
Resto druid

[Deawo]

I run with this setup, not so good, but no problem reach 11/12hc - 2 saves after Litch kill.

Tanks: warrior, blood DK
DPS: fury warrior, ret. paladin, hunter, hunter, shadow
Heals: holy paladin, shaman, drood ( Moonkin off)

Skill >>> Setup

[Wixwix]

Tanks:
Protection Paladin
Frost/Blood Death Knight

Healers:
Discipline Priest
Restoration Druid
Holy Paladin

DPS:
Arcane Mage
Elemental Shaman
Marksman Hunter
Combat Rogue
Warlock

[Wayton]

My group that never really fails and we usually get 8/12 or so with pugs is:

Tanks:
Me (Prot paladin)
Frost death knight

Healers:
Resto Druid
Holy Paladin

DPS:
Elemental shaman (with resto OS)
MM Hunter
Combat Rogue
Destro Warlock
Fury warrior
Shadow priest (with healer OS if shaman doesn't have one)

Never ceases to fail yet so i like the setup

[Deleted]

Tanks: Paladin and Warrior
Healers: Resto Druid, Holy Paladin
Dps: MM Hunter, UH Dk, Feral Druid, Arc Mage, Shadow Priest ( holy OS ) and Retri Paladin

[yeto]

My setup is build arownd what my friends played

Disp/shadow priest
Holy/Shadow Priest
Prot/retpala x 2
Fury/prot warrior
Resto/balance druid
Arcane mage
Hunter
Elemental shaman
Affli lock
9/12 hardmodes down, 3hrs raid per week, and not overgrered via 25mans or well, i was, but the rest were just 232/245 geared when we startet

[Deleted]

Basicly what everybody is saying:
2 tanks , class doesn't matter
3 healers, class doesn't matter , at least 1 needs to have dps offspec
5 dps - class doesn't matter , try to get some synergy between them so they 'boost' eachothers dps (aka a boomkin and the rest all melee is kinda not that).
1 person should be a shammie for BL.

^^

[Duilliath]

What would be the best 10man raid setup and why?

2 non-retarded tanks
2 non-retarded healers
6 non-retarded dps, possibly one with healing off-spec.

//edit:

1 of each class

for epicness

spec as necessary

Though I have to say I like that setup as well.

[Zerenty]

The general answer would be; what ever your guild plays the best.

but here is my ideal setup

Tanks:
Prot warr
Prot pala

DPS:
DK
Rogue
Hunter
Mage
Warlock

Healers:
Holy pala
Rshammy
Disc priest