Heroic Sharpened Twilight Scale > Heroic Death's Choice > Sharpened Twilight Scale > Heroic Whispering Fanged Skull > Death's Choice > Herkuml War Token > Heroic Deathbringer's Will > Whispering Fanged Skull > Deathbringer's Will > Greatness (STR).
Trinket listing taken from EJ.
The Heroic scale will indeed be our BiS, with the reg scale still beating out a majority of the other trinkets, thanks to the AP proc on it.