Your perfect 10.

[twinkleblur]

so what would be ur pefect group for a 10 man. this is probibly gonna be completely based off of what class you play as i know it would be for me.

my 10 are

1. ele/resto shaman (me)
2. Destro lock
3. arcane mage
4. pally tank
5. druid (feral both cat and bear) makes good for those 1 tank fights
6. resto druid
7. holy pally
8. unhioly DK (agian im thinking of caster buffs)
9. combat rogue( this 1 is for buffing the DK and himself ofcouse) besides rogues are useful in a pince for crap
10. priest (healing and shadow can go both ways depending on the fight)

[Deleted]

switch the paladin tank,take a warrior instead, let the priest spec discipline and you have my list

[Deleted]

Prot pala
Feral druid

Holy Pala
Holy Priest

Moonkin
Mage
Hunter

Enhance shammy
Rogue
Any plate melee as last

[Mondroc]

I don't have a perfect setup, in my guild we can make most things work assuming 2 tanks, 2-3 healers. I guess our "standard" setup would be:

1. Druid tank
2. Warrior tank
3. Resto druid
4. Holy priest (Mostly Shadow, Holy on the fights that we use 3 healers for)
5. Resto shaman
6. Retri Paladin
7. Combat Rogue
8. Shadow Priest
9. Demo Warlock
10. MM Hunter

Can't say it's the most ideal setup but there are no massive flaws in it either - Not that we've discovered so far.

[widowmaker]

"rogues are useful in a pince for crap"

say what, now? what d'ya mean?

[xionkarl]

Dream comps!? yay


1. Protection Paladin
2. Blood Death Knight (Tank)
3. Destruction Warlock
4. Balance Druid.
5. Shadow Priest
6. Affliction Warlock
7. Assassination Rogue
8. Elemental Shaman (OS - Restoration)
9. Holy Paladin
10. Discipline/Holy Priest (He plays both specs really well)

[Deleted]

Hmm

Blood DK (Me)
Prot Paladin

Holy Paladin
Discipline Priest

Shadow Priest
MM Hunter
Affliction Warlock
Elemental Shaman
Balance Druid
Fury Warrior


Favouring caster synergy since they are favoured in ICC, while still bringing a pure melee for the fights where it's needed.

[erwin121]

1 Prot warrior
2 feral tank/ cat offspec
3 resto druid (best raidhealer imo)
4 paladin healer (best tankhealer)
5 enhancement shaman
6 retridin/tank offspec
7 shadowpriest/disc offspec
8 arcane mage
9 ele shaman
10 demo lock

[randommagic]

1 Prot Warr
2 Prot Pala
3 Balance Druid
4 Elemental Shaman
5 Arcane Mage
6 Arcane mage
7 Demo Warlock
8 Holy Priest
9 Holy Pala
10 Restro Druid

[Deleted]

Prot Paladin
Feral Druid

Holy Paladin
Resto Druid

Balance Druid
MM/Surv Hunter
Fire/Arcane Mage

Enhancement Shaman
Fury warrior
Combat Rogue

[twinkleblur]

"rogues are useful in a pince for crap"

say what, now? what d'ya mean?

misdirects,trap removals oh and i said combat because of savage combat.

[Serenais]

1) Protection paladin
2) Protection paladin
3) Discipline priest
4) Restoration shaman
5) Retribution/holy paladin
6) Destruction warlock
7) Marksmanship hunter
8) Marksmanship hunter
9) Assassination rogue
10) Feral druid

This is the group I do ICC with.

Alternatively:
1) Protection paladin
2) Protection warrior / Protection paladin
3) Restoration shaman
4) Discipline priest
5) Retribution paladin
6) Balance druid
7) Frost Death Knight
8) Marksmanship hunter
9) Retribution paladin / Fury warrior
10) Arcane / Frost mage

Which is the best my guild has to offer.

[Mudkiper]

2. Destro lock
3. arcane mage

Destro and Arcane ? :X Why not fire and affy.

[widowmaker]

Destro and Arcane ? :X Why not fire and affy.

Destro = higher DPS than Affli, Arcane = Focus Magic (and in some cases more DPS than Fire)

[Smoopie]

prot pally
prot war
holy pally
resto shaman
6 whatevers

[Deleted]

hmm perfect 10, that would be:

me
9 other non-retarded players

[Trayke]

Destro = higher DPS than Affli, Arcane = Focus Magic (and in some cases more DPS than Fire)

Actually the numbers are so close between destro and affliction that it's not even worth arguing over. You may as well argue over player competence at that point...

[Socialhealer]

everyone who said arcane mage, check world of logs once in a while, fire mages are pulling thousands more dps.

[jchunn]

1) Protection paladin
2) Protection paladin
3) Discipline priest
4) Restoration shaman
5) Retribution/holy paladin
6) Destruction warlock
7) Marksmanship hunter
8) Marksmanship hunter
9) Assassination rogue
10) Feral druid

This is the group I do ICC with.

Alternatively:
1) Protection paladin
2) Protection warrior / Protection paladin
3) Restoration shaman
4) Discipline priest
5) Retribution paladin
6) Balance druid
7) Frost Death Knight
8) Marksmanship hunter
9) Retribution paladin / Fury warrior
10) Arcane / Frost mage

Which is the best my guild has to offer.

I wonder what class/spec you play...

[twinkleblur]

i choose arcane over fire mage for a few reasons. more than just the crit buff he can give 1 player an arcane mage brings a 3% damage increase buff for all casters with in range fire may be stronger but group synergy its lacking. also destro over affliction because if i bring an affliction lock it will gymp his dps a good 9% because hes needed to put a different curse on the boss.

---------- Post added 2010-07-19 at 03:07 PM ----------

everyone who said arcane mage, check world of logs once in a while, fire mages are pulling thousands more dps.

yes but thats probibly with the synergy of the following classes.

destro lock,ele sham or demo lock, arcane mage, moonkin. see? there getting buffs from everywhere