This is from a Horde point of view:
Is capping Snowfall Graveyard truly ALWAYS a bad move for the Horde?
Now at 80 it seems AV truly is a race...w the gear on most tanks and heals Van doesn't stand a chance even if he has some of his lieutenants still up to aid him. At 80 i recognize that SFGY can slow the whole bg down quite a bit. Pre-80 it seems most times you really do want defend your towers and bases...defend bal...while making progress north and capping enemy bases. You cant just always race to van and expect to win. So if your team is taking the time and effort to defend bal etc...why should we just let them have SFGY and spawn behind the major offensive force? I've been in plenty really fun AV (especially pre 80) where we D bal...someone caps sfgy (and of course gets shit for it over chat) and then we proceed to completely dominate the BG and get perfection. I could be wrong...but it seems that all the people who jump all over chat with "OMG what noob capped sf? l2play!" really don't want to fight...they want to race. The idea of forcing your enemy back as you fight forward seems much closer to what a battle is than hey lets just let them by to sack our towers while we do likewise.
Anyway I did not mean this to be a rant...was just looking for the mmochamp pvp community's ideas on the matter.