Try Rahxephon and Fafner both are similar to EVA in many ways. Other than those name some other genres you enjoy and i'll match as best i can.
---------- Post added 2012-09-25 at 11:57 AM ----------
Forgot about clothing. In whoch cas ei also have
A Tsubasa chronicles necklace(welll three one of Fais staff and another of the wing sign and last Sakuras feather.)
The anti fire necklace from Shakugan no Shana
two Tsuabas leather wristbands of the half moon symbol
Persona 3 Portable LE Junpei Hat
1-2 Hellsing leather wristbands
1-2 Death note leather wristbands
a sould eater Death mask ski mask/beanie
a naruto ski mask/beanie
A negima hexagram necklace
a Hellsing hexagram necklace
4-6 naruto gloves(2-4 of leaf village and another 2 anti leaf)
a now dead FMA pocket watch.
the LE Rose Signet Ring from Utena
2 FMP wristbands of the Mithril emblem
1-2 sailor moon wristbands
1 of the symbol for Zero from Megaman X
1 Haruhi bracelet
1 haruhi necklace
2 Gurren Lagann wristabands
6-10 negima wristbands
A Gurren Lagann Waterproof Flag
a LE table flag from Chrome Shelled Regios
annnd that is all that i can recall/find i'm pretty sure i have more and this is of course skipping keychains of which i have several LE ones(two from yu yu hakusho one from ride back another from FLCL and so on) and a few regular purchases(chamo-kun and a few others).
So yeah yet again outside of figs i got all y'all beat.